B2U4DevelopingIdeasActivity1.MatchthebookswiththemoviesorTVplays.伊利亞特京華煙云駱駝祥子福爾摩斯了不起的蓋茨比紅樓夢Haveyoueverreadanyofthesebooks?Whataretheyabout?Bytheendoftheclass,Iwillbeableto: 1)understandthereasonsbehindtheunsuccessfulmoviesbasedonbooks;

2)

analyze/??n?la?z/theorganisationofthispassage

3)thinkcriticallyaboutmakingjudgements LearningObjectives(學習目標):Lead-in

TroyisadaptedfromTheIliadbyHomer(荷馬)GoodBook,BadMovie?2.while-reading1.Skimthepassageandchoosethegenre(體裁)A:NarrativewritingB:ExpositoryessayC:Argumentativeessay2.What'stheauthor'spointofviewtowardsmovieadaptations?unsuccessful√Argument:Alltoooften,

greatwords

endupbeingturnedintocinematic“turkeys”O(jiān)rganisation--Argumentunsuccessfulmoviese.g.

TheOdysseyTheGreatGatsbyAliceinWonderlandTips:Exampleshereareusedtoprovideadditionalinformation3.Howdoestheauthormakehispointofviewpersuasive?2.while-readingBygivingreasonsandusingexamplesArgument:Alltoooften,greatwordsendupbeingturnedintocinematic“turkeys”Reason1:TimelimitReason2:Differentfromreaders’imaginationLossofcharactersanddetails,e.g.HarryPotter“Helen—themostbeautifulwomanintheworld”e.g.TroyOrganisation--argumentatione.g.

TheOdysseyTheGreatGatsbyAliceinWonderlandTips:Exampleshereareusedtosupportanarugument2.while-reading4.Whatconclusiondoestheauthordraw?Argument:Alltoooften,greatwordsendupbeingturnedintocinematic“turkeys”Reason1:TimelimitReason2:Differentfromreaders’imaginationLossofcharactersanddetails,e.g.HarryPotter“Helen—themostbeautifulwomanintheworld”e.g.TroyOrganisation--Conclusione.g.

TheOdysseyTheGreatGatsbyAliceinWonderlandConclusion:Judgeamovieinitsownright.3.Post-reading–-makingjudgementsBasedonthepassage,whatdoes“judgeamovieinitsownright”mean?

weshouldjudgeamovieaccordingthestandardsofamoviebutnotwhetheritistruetotheoriginalbook.Canyouthinkofothersituationswherethisexpressionapplies（適用）?inone'sabilityActivity5

Readforfurtherthinking.1.Whatdoesthesaying“ThereareathousandHamletsinathousandpeople’seyes”mean?DoyouknowofanysimilarsayingsinChinese?2.Whatotherreasonsdoyouthinkmakemovieadaptationslesssatisfactorythantheoriginalbooks?Itmeansreadersusuallyhavedifferentideasabouthowthecharactersfromacertainnovelshouldlooklike.Thedescriptionintheoriginalbooksleavesroomforreaderstoimaginewhilethemoviecan’t.仁者見仁，智者見智Reviewing.值得以...結束表揚，稱贊/被稱贊為...關鍵原因細節(jié)各種各樣的評價問題不辜負在一定程度上而且不同的媒體形式原始版本在最近幾年本身，憑自己改編/改編成觀點beworthdoingsthendupdoing/endupwithpraise/bepraisedaskeyreasondetailmixedreviewsissueliveuptotosomeextentfurthermore/besidesdifferentformsofmediaoriginalsourceinrece