個(gè)人收集整理資料，僅供交流學(xué)習(xí)，勿作商業(yè)用途個(gè)人收集整理資料，僅供交流學(xué)習(xí)，勿作商業(yè)用途#/19下表是漢密爾頓縣的法庭1994－1996年間處理的所有案件以及上訴和被推翻原判的情況。中級(jí)訴訟庭法官處理案件總數(shù)上訴案件總數(shù)推翻原判案件數(shù)目FredCartolano303713712ThomasCrush337211910PatrickDinkelacker1258448TinothyHogan1954607RobertKraft31381277WilliamMathews22649118WilliamMorrissey303212122NorbertNadel295913120ArthurNey,Jr.321912514RichardNiehaus335313716ThomasNurre30001216JonhO'Connor296912912RobertRuehlman320514518J.HowardSundermann9556010AnnMarieTracey314112713RalphWinkler3089886合計(jì)439451762199

民事庭法官處理案件總數(shù)上訴案件總數(shù)推翻原判案件數(shù)目PenelopeCunningham272971PatrickDinkelacker6001194DeborahGaines8799489RonaldPanioto12970323合計(jì)3049910617地方庭法官處理案件總數(shù)上訴案件總數(shù)推翻原判案件數(shù)目MikeAllen6149434NadineAllen7812346TimothyBlack7954416DavidDavis7736435LeslieIsaiahGaines52823513KarlaGrady525360DeidraHair253250DennisHelmick7900295TimothyHogan2308132JamesPatrickKenney279861JosephLuebbers4698258WilliamMallory8277389MelbaMarsh8219347BethMattingly2971131AlbertMestemaker4975289MarkPainter223973JackRosen77904113MarkSchweiker5403336DavidStockdate5371224JohnA.West279742合計(jì)108464500104管理報(bào)告:準(zhǔn)備對(duì)法官們進(jìn)行評(píng)定的報(bào)告。并且要包含有關(guān)在三個(gè)法庭中上訴和推翻原判的可能性分析。你的報(bào)告至少應(yīng)包括以下內(nèi)容：6ewMyirQFL在三個(gè)不同法庭中案件被上訴和推翻原判的概率。各個(gè)法官所處理的案件被上訴的概率。各個(gè)法官所處理的案件被推翻原判的概率。對(duì)于一名法官，給定其處理的案件被上訴的條件下，推翻原判的概率。對(duì)每一法庭的法官們進(jìn)行評(píng)定。闡述你用來(lái)作為評(píng)定依據(jù)的標(biāo)準(zhǔn)。管理報(bào)告1.三個(gè)不同法庭中案件被上訴和推翻原判的概率法庭中級(jí)訴訟庭民事庭地方庭被上訴的概率〈％）4.00.40.5推翻原判的概率〈％）0.50.060.102.各個(gè)法官所處理的案件被上訴的概率中級(jí)訴訟庭法官處理案件總上訴案件總被上訴的概率

數(shù)數(shù)〈％）FredCartolano30371374.51ThomasCrush33721193.53PatrickDinkelacker1258443.50TinothyHogan1954603.07RobertKraft31381274.05WilliamMathews2264914.02WilliamMorrissey30321214.00NorbertNadel29591314.43ArthurNey,Jr.32191253.88RichardNiehaus33531374.09ThomasNurre30001214.03JonhO'Connor29691294.34RobertRuehlman32051454.52J.HowardSundermann955606.28AnnMarieTracey31411274.04RalphWinkler3089882.85民事庭法官處理案件總數(shù)上訴案件總數(shù)被上訴的概率<%）PenelopeCunningham272970.26PatrickDinkelacker6001190.32DeborahGaines8799480.55RonaldPanioto12970320.25地方庭法官處理案件總數(shù)上訴案件總數(shù)被上訴的概率〈％）

MikeAllen6149430.70NadineAllen7812340.44TimothyBlack7954410.52DavidDavis7736430.56LeslieIsaiahGaines5282350.66KarlaGrady525360.11DeidraHair253250.20DennisHelmick7900290.37TimothyHogan2308130.56JamesPatrickKenney279860.21JosephLuebbers4698250.53WilliamMallory8277380.46MelbaMarsh8219340.41BethMattingly2971130.44AlbertMestemaker4975280.56MarkPainter223970.31JackRosen7790410.53MarkSchweiker5403330.61DavidStockdate5371220.41JohnA.West279740.143.各個(gè)法官所處理的案件被推翻原判的概率中級(jí)訴訟庭法官處理案件總數(shù)推翻原判案件數(shù)目推翻原判的概率〈％）FredCartolano3037120.40ThomasCrush3372100.30PatrickDinkelacker125880.64TinothyHogan195470.36RobertKraft313870.22

WilliamMathews2264180.80WilliamMorrissey3032220.73NorbertNadel2959200.68ArthurNey,Jr.3219140.43RichardNiehaus3353160.48ThomasNurre300060.2JonhO'Connor2969120.40RobertRuehlman3205180.56J.HowardSundermann955101.05AnnMarieTracey3141130.41RalphWinkler308960.19民事庭法官處理案件總數(shù)推翻原判案件數(shù)目推翻原判的概率〈％）PenelopeCunningham272910.04PatrickDinkelacker600140.07DeborahGaines879990.10RonaldPanioto1297030.02地方庭法官處理案件總數(shù)推翻原判案件數(shù)目推翻原判的概率〈％）MikeAllen614940.07NadineAllen781260.08TimothyBlack795460.08DavidDavis773650.06LeslieIsaiahGaines5282130.25KarlaGrady525300

DeidraHair253200DennisHelmick790050.06TimothyHogan230820.09JamesPatrickKenney279810.04JosephLuebbers469880.17WilliamMallory827790.11MelbaMarsh821970.09BethMattingly297110.03AlbertMestemaker497590.18MarkPainter223930.13JackRosen7790130.17MarkSchweiker540360.11DavidStockdate537140.07JohnA.West279720.074.對(duì)于一名法官，給定其處理的案件被上訴的條件下，推翻原判的概率。設(shè)事件人=案件被推翻原判，事件B=案件被上訴，則P（A/B〉=案件被上訴條件下推翻原判的概率。由條件概率公式：P（A/B〉=P〈AGB）/P〈B）kavU42VRUs則對(duì)于一名法官，給定其處理的案件被上訴的條件下，推翻原判的概率分別為：中級(jí)訴訟庭法官上訴案件總數(shù)推翻原判案件數(shù)目案件被上訴的條件下推翻原判的概率（%>FredCartolano137128.76ThomasCrush119108.40

PatrickDinkelacker44818.18TinothyHogan60711.67RobertKraft12775.51WilliamMathews911819.78WilliamMorrissey1212218.18NorbertNadel1312015.27ArthurNey,Jr.1251411.2RichardNiehaus1371611.68ThomasNurre12164.96JonhO'Connor129129.30RobertRuehlman1451812.41J.HowardSundermann601016.67AnnMarieTracey1271310.24RalphWinkler8866.82民事庭法官上訴案件總數(shù)推翻原判案件數(shù)目案件被上訴的條件下推翻原判的概率(%〉PenelopeCunningham7114.29PatrickDinkelacker19421.05DeborahGaines48918.75RonaldPanioto3239.38地方庭法官上訴案件總數(shù)推翻原判案件數(shù)目案件被上訴的條件下推翻原判的概率(%>MikeAllen4349.30

NadineAllen34617.65TimothyBlack41614.63DavidDavis43511.63LeslieIsaiahGaines351337.14KarlaGrady600DeidraHair500DennisHelmick29517.24TimothyHogan1328JamesPatrickKenney6116.67JosephLuebbers25832WilliamMallory38923.68MelbaMarsh34720.59BethMattingly1317.69AlbertMestemaker28932.14MarkPainter7342.86JackRosen411331.71MarkSchweiker33618.18DavidStockdate22418.18JohnA.West42505.對(duì)每一法庭的法官們進(jìn)行評(píng)定，闡述你用來(lái)作為評(píng)定依據(jù)的標(biāo)準(zhǔn)?；旧峡梢杂糜擅课环ü賵?zhí)行的案件在被上訴的條件下被推翻原判的概率來(lái)評(píng)定一個(gè)法官。如果這個(gè)值比較高，則說(shuō)明這個(gè)法官的執(zhí)法相對(duì)差一些；如果這個(gè)值比較低，則說(shuō)明這個(gè)法官的執(zhí)法相對(duì)公正。y6v3ALoS89在對(duì)各個(gè)法庭進(jìn)行評(píng)定之前，計(jì)算各法庭的幾項(xiàng)指標(biāo)如下：法庭中級(jí)訴訟庭民事庭地方庭被上訴的概率〈％）4.00.40.5推翻原判的概率〈％）0.50.060.1案件