ENABLING

NORTHAMERICANGRAPHITEGROWTHAREPORTFOR

THENORTHAMERICANGRAPHITE

ALLIANCEFEBRUARY

2024ABOUT

OXFORDECONOMICSOxfordEconomicswas

foundedin1981asacommercialventurewithOxfordUniversity’sbusinesscollegetoprovideeconomicforecastingandmodellingto

UKcompaniesandfinancialinstitutionsexpandingabroad.Sincethen,we

havebecomeoneoftheworld’s

foremostindependentglobaladvisoryfirms,providingreports,forecastsandanalyticaltoolson

morethan200countries,100industries,and8,000citiesandregions.Ourbest-in-classglobal

economicandindustrymodelsandanalyticaltoolsgiveusanunparalleledabilitytoforecastexternalmarket

trendsand

assesstheireconomic,socialandbusinessimpact.Headquartered

inOxford,

England,

with

regionalcenters

in

New

York,

London,

Frankfurt,

and

Singapore,Oxford

Economics

has

offices

across

theglobe

in

Belfast,Boston,Cape

Town,

Chicago,

Dubai,

Dublin,

HongKong,

Los

Angeles,

Mexico

City,Milan,

Paris,

Philadelphia,

Stockholm,

Sydney,

Tokyo,and

Toronto.

Weemploy

600staff,

including

more

than

350

professionaleconomists,

industry

experts,

and

businesseditors—one

ofthe

largest

teams

of

macroeconomists

and

thought

leadership

specialists.

Our

global

teamis

highlyskilled

in

a

full

range

of

research

techniquesand

thought

leadership

capabilities

from

econometricmodelling,

scenarioframing,

and

economic

impact

analysis

to

market

surveys,case

studies,

expert

panels,and

web

analytics.OxfordEconomicsis

akeyadvisertocorporate,financialandgovernmentdecision-makersandthoughtleaders.Ourworldwideclientbasenowcomprisesover

2,000internationalorganizations,includingleadingmultinationalcompaniesandfinancialinstitutions;keygovernmentbodiesandtradeassociations;andtopuniversities,

consultancies,

andthinktanks.FEBRUARY2024Alldatashownintables

andcharts

areOxfordEconomics’owndata,exceptwhereotherwisestatedandcitedinfootnotes,and

arecopyright?OxfordEconomicsLtd.Themodelling

andresultspresentedhereare

basedon

informationprovidedbythirdparties,uponwhichOxfordEconomicshas

relied

inproducingitsreportandforecastsingoodfaith.

Anysubsequentrevisionorupdateofthosedatawillaffectthe

assessmentsand

projectionsshown.Todiscussthereportfurtherpleasecontact:HamiltonGalloway:hgalloway@OxfordEconomics5HanoverSq,8thFloorNewYork,

NY10004Tel:+1646-786-1879TABLEOF

CONTENTSExecutivesummary41.Introduction62.Theglobalgraphitemarket72.1Graphitedemand

72.2Graphitesupply

82.3Anodematerial113.Rationalesfortradeaction163.1Infantindustryprotection173.2Unfairtradepractices

193.3

Strategicprotection244.GraphiteandSection301Tariffs

284.1Section301tariffs

in

2018284.2Chineseexportrestrictionsongraphite

294.3ArgumentsforrenewedSection301tariffsonChinesegraphite

295.Conclusion31EXECUTIVESUMMARYTHEGLOBALGRAPHITEMARKETGlobaldemandforgraphite

hasexpanded52%inthe

lastfive

yearsandisexpectedtogrowanother70%overthenextfiveyears.Thisdemandgrowthhas

largelybeendrivenbyincreaseddemandforlithium-ionbatteries(LiBs),drivenbyelectricvehicleproduction.Demandforanodematerial—theformofgraphiteusedinLiBs—isprojectedtoalmosttripleinthe

nextfive

years.Chinacurrentlydominatestheglobalgraphitemarket,

and,barring

concertedaction,

itwillcontinuetodoso.AccordingtoforecastsbyBenchmarkMineralIntelligence,

Chinasupplied72%ofallgraphitein2023andisprojectedto

supply65%ofallgraphitein2028,.Chinaaccountsforanevenlargershareofthemarketforthehigh-puritygraphiteanodematerialusedinbatteries.

In2023,Chinacontrolled92%ofthismarket,andit

isforecasttoaccountfor86%oftheanodematerialmarket

in2028,accordingtoBenchmark.Chinadominatestheproductionofbothnaturalgraphite,whichisminedfromthegroundandlaterrefinedintoanodematerial,aswellassyntheticgraphite,whichismanufacturedfrompetroleum.AccordingtoBenchmark,China’s

supplyofanodematerial

exceededglobaldemandby32%in2023;howeverglobaldemandisgrowingsoquicklythatit

willcatchup

tothissupplyby

2024.

Becauseofthisrapidlyrisingdemand,

China

continuestoinvestin

graphitemanufacturingdespiteits

currentovercapacity.Thepriceofanodematerialmadefromsyntheticgraphitefellby24%

from2022to

2023andisexpectedtofallby38%fromits2022peak

by2026.Thisrapidfallinpricesandtheconvergenceofthepriceof

syntheticgraphitewiththat

ofnaturalgraphiteisindicativeof

Chinasellingitsoversupplyofgraphiteatpricesthatdonotreflectthe

full

costofproduction.RATIONALESFORTRADEACTIONThegeneral

economicargumentforfreetradeiswell

established;however,tradeprotectionscanbejustifiedunderseveralconditions:1)

Infantindustryprotections

arejustifiedwhen

nascentindustriesfacecostdisadvantagesowingtoincreasedscaleby

establishedplayers,ordecliningcostsfromlearningby

doing.NorthAmericangraphiteproducersface

significanthurdlestoobtaininginvestment

inthefaceofexcessChinese

capacityingraphitemanufacturing.SecuringareliablesourceofgraphiteisalsocriticaltothesuccessofthegrowingNorthAmericanLiBandEVmanufacturingsectorsas

well.2)

Tradeprotectioncanbejustified

asaresponseto

unfairtradepractices

bytheexporter,includingdumping,governmentsubsidies,unfairand

harmfulregulation,

andforcedtechnologytransfer.

Chinahasalongandwell-documentedhistoryofthesepracticesacrossanumberofgoods,forexample,inthecaseofphotovoltaicsolarpanelsin

the2010s.Chineseovercapacityingraphiteproduction,combinedwiththefallingpriceofgraphitein

recentyears(thepriceofnaturalgraphitefell18%in2023,while

thatofsyntheticgraphitefell24%)4EnablingNorthAmericanGraphiteGrowthsuggestthatthepriceatwhichChinais

sellinggraphitehasdecoupledfromthecostofproduction.3)

Strategicprotections

can

bejustifiedbasedonnationalsecurityconsiderations.

LiBsareacriticalcomponentofmany

emergingadvancedtechnologies,includingmanywithnationalsecurity

applications.Graphitehasbeendesignated

acriticalmineralforLiBproductionbythreeUSgovernmentagencies,andtheUSgovernmenthasmadesignificantinvestmentsthroughgrantsandtaxpolicychangesincludedintwo

U.S.laws,theInfrastructureInvestmentandJobsActin2021andthe

InflationReductionActin

2022,

inincreasingdomesticgraphiteproduction.4)

Poorlaborandenvironmental

practicesprovideanotherjustificationfortradeaction,bothtolimittheunfairadvantagethatfirmswith

suchpractices

enjoy,

aswellas

todiscouragethepracticesthemselves.

Chinesegraphiteproducersgenerate

substantialcarbon

emissionsowingtoinefficientindustrialprocessesand

anoverrelianceondirty

energysourcessuch

ascoal.Theyhavealsobeenlinkedtostate-sponsored

“l(fā)abortransfer”programsaffectingworkersin

theUighurAutonomousregionthathavebeendescribed

asforcedlabor.GRAPHITEANDSECTION

301TARIFFSStartingin2018,theUShasappliedtariffs(raisedto25%in2019)on

approximately$500billionofChinesegoods,includingmanyproductsmadefromgraphite

under

section301oftheTradeActof1974.Thesetariffswerenotspecifictographitebutwerepartofabroadertariffpackagein

responsetounfairtradepracticesbyChina.However,in

2020,

theUSTrade

RepresentativeapprovedarequestfromEVmanufacturersto

exemptmostgraphiteanodematerialusedinbatteriesfromthese

301tariffssincemanufacturersarguedthattheywereunabletosourceanadequatesupplyofgraphite

fromnon-Chinesesources.WhileBenchmarkforecastscorroboratetheChinesedominanceoftheglobalgraphitemarket,

thisraisesachicken-and-eggproblem:domesticgraphitemanufacturerscannot

secureexternalinvestmentsandmakethenecessary

internalinvestmentstoincreasetheirfutureproductionabsentprotectionfromChina’ssignificantovercapacityingraphitemanufacturing.Absenttheseprotections,therefore,itwillcontinueto

beimpossiblefordomesticLiBmanufacturerstoobtaingraphitefromnon-Chinesesources.EnablingNorthAmericanGraphiteGrowth1.INTRODUCTIONGraphiteisanon-metallicmineral,which,likecoal

anddiamond,isaformofpurecarbon.Graphiteisveryresistanttoheatandisrelatively

chemicallyinert,twopropertiesthat

makeit

usefulincertaintypesofmanufacturing.Traditionally,graphitehasbeeninhighdemandinthe

steelindustry,whereitisusedinrefractories(bricksthatlineblastfurnaces),

andforelectrodesinelectricarcfurnaces;as

wellasinanumberofotherindustrialprocesses.Graphiteisalsoacrucialcomponentoflithium-ionbatteries(LiBs),makingupabout

30%ofLiBsbyweight,

butaccountingforonlyabout

12%oftheircost.

Therecent

andprojected

expansioninthe12demandforLiBshas

resultedinamassiveincreasein

bothdomesticandglobaldemandforgraphite.AccordingtoforecastsbyBenchmarkMineralIntelligence,

thedemandforgraphiteisexpectedtogrow70%inthenextfiveyears,while

thedemandfor

graphite-derived

anodematerialusedinbatteriesisexpectedtonearlytriple.

EnsuringareliablesupplyofgraphiteiscriticalforthemanufactureofLiBsandfor

theproductionofelectricvehicles(EVs),whichareexpectedtoincreasinglydominateautomobileproductionin

thecomingyears.Thisreport,whichwascommissionedby

theNorthAmericanGraphiteAlliance,a

coalitionofNorthAmericangraphiteproducers,reviewstheeconomicsof

theglobalgraphitemarket,theargumentsfortraderestrictionsinNorth

America,and

therecentinstitutionaltradecontext.Theremainderof

thepaperisorganizedasfollows:??Chapter2presentsaquantitativeoverviewoftheglobalgraphitemarket.Chapter3discusses

theeconomicrationaleforprotectingNorthAmericangraphiteproductionagainstcompetitionfromChinesegraphiteimports.Chapter4reviewsthistradehistory.??Chapter5concludes.1

See,forexample,/the-key-minerals-in-an-ev-battery/.TheWorldBankGroupestimatedthatgraphiteaccountsforapproximately54%byweightofthe“mineraldemand”neededforenergystoragethrough2050.SeeKirstenHund,DanieleLa

Porta,ThaoP.Fabregas,TimLaingandJohnDrexhage(2020).“MineralsforClimateAction:TheMineralIntensityofthe

CleanEnergyTransition.”/en/961711588875536384/Minerals-for-Climate-Action-The-Mineral-Intensity-of-the-Clean-Energy-Transition.pdf.2

See,forexample,/breaking-down-the-cost-of-an-ev-battery-cell/.Mostofthebattery’sanodeismadefromgraphite,whichaccountsformostoftheanode’sapproximately12%shareofthecost.EnablingNorthAmericanGraphiteGrowth2.THE

GLOBALGRAPHITEMARKET2.1GRAPHITEDEMANDGlobaldemandforgraphiteisrobustandhas

beenrisingoverrecentyears.

AccordingtodatafromBenchmarkMineralIntelligence,

demandtotaledapproximately3.6millionmetrictonsin2023(Fig.31).Thebulkofthisdemand

wasforthreeuses:

almosthalfisfor

electrodesusedin

steelproduction,morethanathirdforuseinbatteries,

and

around

atenthforrefractoryandfoundrymaterials.Othersmallerusesforgraphiteincludedexpandedgraphite,

whichis

usedasaflameretardant;carburization;frictionproducts;

andgraphiteshapes,lubricants,andcarbonbrushes.Fig.1.Globalgraphitedemandbyuse,2023Frictionproducts(1%)Expanded

graphite

(2%)Refractory

&foundryBattery(38%)Electrode(46%)20233,619(11%)Carburisation

(1%)Otheruses(1%)05001,0001,5002,0002,5003,0003,5004,000Thousands

ofmetric

tonsSource:

Benchmark

MineralIntelligence,Oxford

EconomicsGlobaldemandforgraphitegrewby52%overthe

five

yearsperiodbetween2018

to2023andisforecasttogrow70%overthe

five-yearperiodfrom2023-2028(Fig.2).Mostofthisgrowth(89%ofthegrowthover

thelastfive

yearsand85%oftheforecastgrowthoverthe

nextfiveyears)is

theresultofincreaseddemand

forgraphitein

batteryproduction.3

BenchmarkMineralIntelligenceforecasts,January2024.EnablingNorthAmericanGraphiteGrowthFig.2.Globalgraphitedemandbyuse,2018-2028Thousands

ofmetric

tons7,0006,167(+70%)Battery6,000Other5,0002,643(+17%)3,619(+52%)4,0003,0002,0001,00002,3792,252(+7%)3,525(+158%)2,1121,367(+412%)267201820232028Source:

Benchmark

MineralIntelligence,Oxford

Economics2.2GRAPHITESUPPLYTherearetwosourcesofgraphite:naturaland

synthetic.Naturalgraphiteismined

fromtheground

asflakegraphiteandlaterprocessedin

variouswaysdependingonthespecificchemicalpropertiesrequired.Syntheticgraphiteismanufacturedfrompetroleum

coke,whichisabyproductoftheoilrefinerybusiness.Typically,syntheticgraphiteis

ofahigherpuritythannatural,althoughnaturalgraphitecanbeprocessedtohighlevelsofpurity.

Syntheticgraphiteisalsotypicallymoreexpensivethannaturalgraphite.Forthisreason,syntheticgraphiteisusedinthe

twoapplicationsofgraphitethatrequirethehighestpurity:electrodesusedinsteelproduction,whichuseexclusivelysyntheticgraphite,andbatteryproduction,whichmakesuse

ofbothnaturalandsyntheticgraphite.Theotherendusesofgraphitedepictedin

Fig.1typicallyuseonlynaturalgraphite.In2023,approximatelytwo-thirdsofthegraphiteused

globallywassyntheticin

origin,withtheremainingthirdbeingnatural.Naturalgraphite’sshareoftheglobalgraphitemarketisforecasttoincreasemodestlyfrom33%in2023to38%in2028.EnablingNorthAmericanGraphiteGrowthFig.3.Graphitesupplybychemistry,2018-2028Thousands

ofmetric

tons8,0006,8627,000Natural6,0005,0004,0003,0002,0001,0000Synthetic62%3,6632,41667%66%38%33%34%201820232028Source:

Benchmark

MineralIntelligence,Oxford

EconomicsChinadominatesthesupplyofbothnatural

andsyntheticgraphite(Fig.4).In2023,Chinasupplied67%ofthenaturalgraphiteusedgloballyand75%ofthesyntheticgraphite;or72%ofgraphiteoverall.AccordingtoBenchmark’sforecast,China’sshareoftheglobalgraphitemarketisexpectedtofallonlyslightlyby2028,to65%,withitsshareofthesyntheticgraphiteincreasing

slightly.TheUS’sshareofgraphiteproductionisexpectedtoremainsteadyat3%from2023to2028,whileCanadaisforecasttoincreaseitsshareofglobalgraphiteproductionfromlessthan

1%to4%EnablingNorthAmericanGraphiteGrowthFig.4.GraphitesupplybychemistryandgeographyUSANaturalSyntheticTotal67%5%1,219CanadaChina75%2,4452,578MozambiqueMadagascarIndia3%72%3,663TanzaniaOtherNaturalSyntheticTotal41%4%80%4,2843%4%4%5%4%65%4%12%6,86201,0002,0003,0004,0005,0006,0007,0008,000Thousands

ofmetric

tonsSource:

Benchmark

MineralIntelligence,Oxford

EconomicsWhileChina’sstatus

asthelargest

producerofnaturalgraphitereflectssignificantdepositsinthecountry—approximately28%ofglobalgraphitereservesaccording

to

theUS

GeologicalSurvey(USGS)—severalother

countriesboastsignificantnaturalgraphitedeposits.However,graphitereservesin

theUS

arebelievedtobe

small(andarenotreportedby

theUSGS),

andotherNorthAmericandepositsaccount

foronlyabout3%ofglobal

reserves

(Fig.5).Fig.5.GraphitereservesMexico1%Canada2%Other19%China28%Tanzania280millionmetrictons6%Madagascar9%MozambiqueBrazil26%9%Source:

USGS,

Oxford

EconomicsEnablingNorthAmericanGraphiteGrowth2.3ANODEMATERIALInthissection,we

focusongraphitethathas

beenprocessedforuseinbatteries,

referredtoas“anodematerial.”

Thedemandforgraphiteanodematerialgrewjustover

six-foldfrom2018to20234andisexpectedtomorethantriplebetween2023and

2028,accordingtoBenchmarkforecasts(Fig.6).Mostofthatincreaseis

theresultofincreaseddemandforEVbatteries,althoughthedemandforenergystoragesystems(ESSorgridstorage)

andforportabledeviceslikecellphonesalsocontributedtotheincreaseddemand.Beyondourfive-yearforecastwindow,some

expertspredictthatgraphitedemandforESSmayexceeddemandfor

EVs.Fig.6.Anodematerialdemandbyenduse,2018-2028Thousands

ofmetric

tons3,5002,920(+189%)3,0002,5002,0001,5001,000500ElectricVehicles(EV)EnergyStorageSystems(ESS)Portables+30%+179%1,010(+506%)+205%+2,725%167+640%+39%0201820232028Source:

Benchmark

MineralIntelligence,

Oxford

EconomicsChinacurrentlyrepresentsjustoverhalf(52%)oftheglobaldemandforanodematerial,whichisessentiallyitsshareofthemarketformanufacturing

LiBs(Fig.7).China’sshareof

thisdemandisexpectedtofallmodestlyto43%by2028,withNorthAmerica’sshareof

theanodematerial

demandincreasingfrom16%to22%.However,

theseforecastsaredependentontheseregions’continuedabilitytoobtainthecriticalrawmaterialsnecessaryforbatteryproduction,includinggraphite.4

Naturalgraphiterequiressignificantrefiningtobeusedinbatteries.Inthis

refiningprocessfornaturalgraphite,approximatelyhalfthegraphitebyweightislost.Syntheticgraphiteismanufacturedtoneed,soitdoesnotexperiencethis

lossofmaterial.Carefulreadingofthefiguresinthis

chapterwillmakethis

clear.

Fig.2showsthat,in2023,thedemand

forgraphite(bothnaturalandsynthetic)inbatterieswasapproximately1.367thousand

metrictons.Fig.6,however,showsa2023demandforanodematerialof1,010thousandmetrictons.Thedifferencelargelyreflectsthelossofmaterialwhennaturalgraphite(whichsuppliesapproximatelyaquarteroftheanodematerial—seeFig.8)isprocessedintoanodematerial.EnablingNorthAmericanGraphiteGrowthFig.7.Anodematerialdemandbyregion,2018-2028Thousands

ofmetric

tons3,5002,920NorthAmericaChina3,0002,5002,0001,5001,00050015%EU21%Other1,01010%21%43%52%16%16722%0201820232028Source:

Benchmark

MineralIntelligence,Oxford

EconomicsIn2023,approximately24%

oftheglobalanode

materialsupplywas

madeupofnaturalgraphite,with74%beingsyntheticgraphite(Fig.8).Theremainderoftheanodematerialmarketwasmadeupofotheranodematerials,includinggraphite-silicon.Fig.8.Anodematerialsupply

by

chemistry,2018-20285Thousands

ofmetric

tons3,5003,0743,0002,5002,0001,5001,000500NaturalSyntheticOther3%75%1,4503%74%2756%28%22%66%24%0201820232028Source:

Benchmark

MineralIntelligence,Oxford

EconomicsChinadominatestheproductionofbothnaturalandsyntheticgraphiteanodematerial.In

2023,Chinaproducedapproximately79%oftheanodematerialmadefromnaturalgraphite,andapproximately97%oftheanodematerialmadefromsyntheticgraphite.

AccordingtoBenchmark,absentintervention,thesesharesareexpectedtofallonlyslightlyby2028,bywhichtimetheUSis

expected5

“Other”includesgraphite-silicon.EnablingNorthAmericanGraphiteGrowthtoaccountforabout3%ofglobalgraphiteanodematerialproduction,andCanadaforanadditional1%(Fig.9).Fig.9.Anodematerialsupply

by

chemistryandgeography,2023-2028NaturalgraphiteUSA79%346CanadaChinaSyntheticgraphite97%1,0664%SouthKoreaJapanAll92%3%

1,450Naturalgraphite72%681OtherSyntheticgraphite91%2,3031%2%All

3%86%3%

5%

3,07405001,0001,5002,0002,5003,0003,500Thousands

ofmetric

tonsSource:

Benchmark

MineralIntelligence,Oxford

EconomicsNotethat,in2023,the

supplyofanodematerialof1,450thousandmetrictons(see

Fig.8),significantlyexceededthedemandforanodematerial

of1,010thousandmetrictons(Fig.

7),accordingtoBenchmarkdata.Whilethislargediscrepancymayin

partreflectmeasurementissues,itisindicativeofoversupplyin

theanodematerialmarketinrecentyears,asChinahasinvestedtomeetexpectedfuturedemandforgraphite(seeFig.10).WhileChinesesupplyofanodematerialwasestimated

toexceedglobal

demandby32%in2023,demandisgrowingsorapidlythatitis

expectedtoexceed

China’s2023supplyof

anodematerialbytheendof2024.Thus,Chinacontinuestoinvestingraphitemanufacturing

despiteitsovercapacityin

anticipationofdominatingrapidlygrowingfuturedemand.EnablingNorthAmericanGraphiteGrowthFig.10.

Supply,demandforanodematerial,2021-2028Thousands

ofmetric

tons3,5003,000Globalsupply2,5002,0001,5001,000500ChinasupplyGlobaldemand020212022202320242025202620272028Source:

Benchmark

MineralIntelligence,Oxford

EconomicsThisChineseovercapacityintheproductionofanodematerialisreflectedinthepriceforanodematerialshowninFig.11.

Afterpeakingin2022,thepriceof

anodematerialfromnaturalgraphitefell618%in2023andisexpectedtofallby27%fromitspeakby2026.Thepriceofanodematerialfromsyntheticgraphitefelleven

more,by24%in2023,andis

expectedtofallby38%by2026.

Withinthiscategoryofhigh-capacitygradegraphiteanodematerial,

thepricepremiumforsyntheticgraphite—whichis

typicallymoreexpensivetomanufacturethannaturalgraphiteisto

extractandrefine—fellfrom25%in2022to15%in

2023

andisexpectedtofallto

5%by2025.Whileadetailed

analysisofthecostofproductionofanodematerialin

ChinaisnotpossibleowingtotheclosednatureofChineseindustry,thisrapidfallin

pricesandthe

convergenceofthepriceofsyntheticgraphitewiththatofnaturalgraphite—alongsidetheestimatesofChineseovercapacityshowninFig.11—isindicativeofChinaselling

graphiteatpricesthatdonotreflectthefull

costofproduction,aspartofan

efforttocapturefuturedemand,aswellas

todisposeofexcesssupply.Thisisdiscussedfurtherinthefollowingchapter,

especiallyinsection3.2onunfairtradepractices.6

Thispricerepresentsthepriceforhigh-capacitygradeanodematerial,whichisthemostwidelyusedgradeofgraphitein

LiBs.ThepriceshownhereisthatprevailinginChina,which,becauseofChina’sdominanceoftheanodematerialmarket(seeFig.9),isthemostrepresentativepriceseriesfortheglobalgraphiteanode

material.EnablingNorthAmericanGraphiteGrowthFig.11.

Realpriceforhigh-capacitygradeanode

materialbychemistry,2021-2028in

China2023

realUS$permetricton$12,000$11,000$10,000$9,000$8,000$7,000$6,00020212022202320242025202620272028Source:

Benchmark

MineralIntelligence,Oxford

EconomicsEnablingNorthAmericanGraphiteGrowth3.RATIONALESFORTRADEACTIONThegeneral

economicbenefitsoffreetradearelongestablished.Notably,free

tradebetweennationsallowsnationstospecializein

sectorswheretheyenjoy

acomparativeadvantageandincreasescompetitionbetweenproducers.Thisresultsinbenefitsfor

consumers(lowerprices

andmore7productvariety

)andhigher

levelsofproductivity.89Thereare,however,severalconditionsunderwhichtradeprotectionmeasures

canbejustifiedtobenefitdomesticbusinessesandconsumers.Theseincludeinfantindustryprotection,protectionagainstunfairtradepractices,andprotectionsdue

tostrategicconcerns.Eachoftheserationalesfortradeprotectionisrelevant

tothe

caseoftheNorthAmericangraphiteindustry:1)

Infantindustries.TheNorthAmericangraphiteindustryisinitsnascencycomparedwiththemoremature

Chinesegraphiteindustry.Duringtheseearlystagesofdevelopment,

domesticgraphiteproducersmayneedtemporarysupportand

protectionfromChinese

competitioninordertogrowintoself-sustainingcompetitivefirms.

A

reliablesupplyofgraphiteis

also

keyforNorthAmerica’sgraphite,EV,anddefenseindustries.2)

Protectionagainstunfairtrade

practices.TheChinesegovernmenthasawell-documentedhistoryofengagingin

unfairtradepracticesthatharmUSindustry,andgraphiteisnoexception.In

2017theUSTRconductedaninvestigationwhichdeterminedthatChinaengagedintrade

practiceswhichburdenedUScommerceacrosshundredsofproducts,includinggraphite.Morerecently,between2021and2023Chinesegraphitesupplyhasexceededglobaldemandandthepriceforhigh-capacitygradeanodematerialfellsharply.Thisexcessproductionand

sharpfallinglobalpricesare

suggestiveofsubsidiesanddumpinginChinesegraphiteandmakeitdifficultforUScompaniesto

enterandoperateinthemarket.3)

Strategicconcerns.GraphiteisakeymineralfortherapidlygrowingEVindustryandlithium-ionbatterieswhichhaveimportantapplicationstomilitaryandadvancedtechnologies.Assuch,tariffsareimportanttoensuretheUS

developsandmaintainsdomesticproductioncapacityofgraphite.4)

Laborandenvironmental

protection.Chinesegraphite

producershavehighergreenhousegasemissions

thanWestern

competitorsowingtotheir

greateruseofcoalpowerandrelativelycheap,inefficient

productionprocesses.FirmsintheChinesebattery

supplychainhavealsobeentiedtostate-sponsored“l(fā)abortransfer”

programs,whichcriticssayamounttoforcedlabor.Theremainderofthis

chapterexplores

eachoftheserationalesfortradeaction

in

moredetail.7

XavierJaravel,andErickSager,‘WhatarethePriceEffectsofTrade?EvidencefromtheU.S.andImplicationsforQuantitativeTradeModels’(August2019).CEPRDiscussionPaperNo.DP13902,AvailableatSSRN:/abstract=34394558

DavidAtkin,Benj