版權(quán)說明:本文檔由用戶提供并上傳,收益歸屬內(nèi)容提供方,若內(nèi)容存在侵權(quán),請(qǐng)進(jìn)行舉報(bào)或認(rèn)領(lǐng)
文檔簡(jiǎn)介
EUROPEANCENTRALBANK
EUROSYSTEM
HannahS.Hempell,FátimaSilva,
ValerioScalone,TamásBorkó,
WandaCornacchia,DomenicaDiVirgilio,AurélienEspic,SalomónGarcia,MarcelHeires, LuisHerrera,SamuK?rkk?inen,LukeKent, StefanKerbl,SebastianL?he,VitorOliveira, SpyrosPalligkinis,AnatoliSeguraVelez,PaulinaSteikūn?
OccasionalPaperSeries
Implicationsofhigherinflationandinterestratesformacroprudentialpolicystance
No358
Disclaimer:ThispublicationshouldnotbereportedasrepresentingtheviewsoftheEuropeanCentralBank(ECB).TheviewsexpressedarethoseoftheauthorsanddonotnecessarilyreflectthoseoftheECB.
ECBOccasionalPaperSeriesNo3581
Contents
Abstract2
Non-technicalsummary3
1Introduction6
1.1Context6
1.2Macroprudentialpolicyinanevolvingmacro-financiallandscape7
BoxA.Overviewofmonetarypolicyconcernsinmacroprudentialnotifications9
2Macroprudentialpolicygivendifferentmonetarypolicystancesandinflationary
dynamics13
2.1Systemicriskatthecurrentjuncture13
2.2Effectivenessofmacroprudentialpolicy15
2.3Interactionswithdifferentmonetarypolicystances17
3Capital-basedmeasuresunderdifferentinflationandmonetarypolicyregimes22
BoxB.Inflation,monetarypolicyandrule-basedcountercyclicalbuffer28
BoxC.Bufferrelease:howmonetarypolicyandinitialbankcapitalisationinfluenceits
effectiveness30
4BBMsundervariousinflationandmonetarypolicyregimes32
4.1BBMsintheeuroarea/EU32
4.2BindingnessofBBMsgivenmacro-financialconditionsandmonetarypolicystance
33
BoxD.BindingnessofBBMsamongeuroareahouseholdsinthecurrentenvironment–
microsimulationsongranularhouseholdsurveydata38
BoxE.Costsandbenefitsofmacroprudentialpolicy:theroleofmonetarypolicyandofthe
structuralfeaturesofthemortgagesector40
5Conclusions44
References48
ECBOccasionalPaperSeriesNo3582
Abstract
Inrecentyears,monetarypolicyandinflationconsiderationshavebeenplayingan
increasinglyimportantroleformacroprudentialauthoritiesintheirpolicysetting.This
paperaimstoassesstheimplicationsofhighinflationandrisinginterestratesformacroprudentialpolicystance.Theconceptualdiscussionsandmodel-based
analysesincludedinthispaperreflectontheappropriatedirectionandimpactofmacroprudentialpoliciesatthedifferentstagesoffinancialandbusinesscycles,givencross-countryandbankingsystemheterogeneities.Inthiscontext,akey
objectiveofthepaperistoassesstowhatextenttheinteractionbetween
macroprudentialandmonetarypoliciesdiffers,giventheheterogeneityacrosseuroareacountriesexposedtoahomogenousmonetarypolicy.Whilebothpoliciesaretoalargeextentcomplementary,monetarypolicymaygeneraterelevantspilloversduetoitsimpactonthefinancialcycleand,potentially,onfinancialstability.Thepaper
arguesthattherecentfocusofmacroprudentialpolicyonresilience,whenbanking
sectorconditionsensurenounwarrantedprocyclicaleffectsofmacroprudential
tightening,suggestsanexpansionofthenotionof“complementarity”withmonetarypolicy.Specifically,withthebuild-upofresilience,macroprudentialpolicyactsde
factocountercyclically,supportingmonetarypolicyinitspursuitofpricestability.In
thisregard,thepaperstressesthatthesourceoftheinflationaryshock(supply
versusdemandside)andthemonetaryenvironmentprimarilyaffecttheintensity,
speedandextentofbufferbuild-uporreleasewithineachstageofthefinancialcyclewhileaffectingborrower-basedmeasuresintheirbindingness.
Keywords:Financialstability,banks,macroprudentialpolicy,monetarypolicy,capitalbuffers,borrower-basedmeasures
JELcodes:E52,G21,G28
ECBOccasionalPaperSeriesNo3583
Non-technicalsummary
Thispaperaimstoassesstheimplicationsofhighinflationandrisinginterest
ratesforthemacroprudentialpolicystance.Monetarypolicyandinflation
considerationshaveplayedanincreasinglyimportantroleformacroprudentialauthoritiesintheirpolicysettingsince2022,asindicatedinnotificationstotheEuropeanSystemicRiskBoard(ESRB)andtheEuropeanCentralBank(ECB).
Againstthisbackground,theanalysesreflectontheappropriatedirectionandontheimpactthatmacroprudentialpolicieshavethroughoutthedifferentphasesoffinancialandbusinesscycles.Thisrequiresanexaminationoftheimpactthat
macroprudentialpolicieshaveonthemitigationofrisksposedbymonetarypolicy
tightening/loosening,consideringalsocross-countryandbankingsystemheterogeneities.
De-synchronisedbusinessandfinancialcyclesandinflationarysupplyshocksinthecontextofthepandemicandgeopoliticaltensionshaveposeda
challengetotheclassicalnotionof“complementarity”between
macroprudentialandmonetarypolicies.Forsynchronisedfinancialandbusinesscycles,asobservedinthemostrecentquarters,wherebothcycleshavestartedtocontractinmosteuroareacountries,complementarymacroprudentialandmonetarypoliciesmaylargelymoveinthesametighteningorlooseningdirection.Bycontrast,de-synchronisedcycles,asobservedinthecontextofthepandemicandthe
inflationarysupplyshocks,havecomplicatedtheinteractionbetweenmacroprudentialandmonetarypolicies.
Macroprudentialpolicybuildsupresilienceand,initsinteractionwith
monetarypolicy,bothpoliciesaretoalargeextentcomplementary,althoughtheremaybetrade-offsintheshortrun.Byincreasingthelossabsorption
capacity(viacapital-basedmeasures)andsafeguardingthelendingstandardsofborrowers(viaborrower-basedmeasures,orBBMs),macroprudentialpolicybuilds
upresilienceamongbanksandborrowers,thushelpingtosupportandstabilisetheflowofcreditinadownturn.However,monetarypolicymaygeneraterelevant
spilloversgivenitsimpactonthefinancialcycleand,potentially,onfinancialstability.
Macroprudentialauthoritieshaverecentlyfocusedonresilience,whichmightsuggestanexpansionofthenotionof“complementarity”withmonetary
policy.Byfocusingonthe(pre-emptive)build-upofresilienceandmacroprudentialspace,whenbankingsectorconditionsensurethisactionhasnounwarranted
procyclicaleffects,macroprudentialpolicyactsdefactocountercyclically,supportingmonetarypolicyinitspursuitofpricestability.Thus,macroprudentialpolicyprovidesspaceformonetarypolicytopursueitstargetsmoreeffectively,withoutrisking
unintendedsideeffectsonfinancialstability.Thismayresultinasynchronous
directionofbothpoliciesdespiteadiversioninbusinessandfinancialcycles.Overall,sufficientloss-absorbingcapacityinthefinancialsystemallowsforthetwokeypolicyobjectives(financialstabilityformacroprudentialpolicyandpricestabilityfor
monetarypolicy)(largely)nottobeinconflict.Moreprecisely,bothpoliciesprimarily
ECBOccasionalPaperSeriesNo3584
focusontheirownobjectivesandmacroprudentialpolicyactsasthefirstlineofdefencetoaddressfinancialstabilityrisks.However,thisdoesnotimplythat
macroprudentialpolicyshouldnotrespondtomonetarypolicystance:ifstrongshiftsinthelatter,irrespectiveofdirection,createadditionalfinancialstabilityrisks,
macroprudentialpolicymighthavetobuildupresilienceagainstsuchvulnerabilities.
Thiscomplementaryroleplayedbymacroprudentialpolicybecomeseven
morerelevantinthecaseofamonetaryunionwithasinglemonetarypolicy
acrossmemberstates.Withitsgranularandtargetedinstruments,macroprudentialpolicyisabletomitigatepotentiallysystemic,asymmetricfinancialdevelopmentsorshocksatthecountry,sectororfinancialinstitutionlevel.Itisthereforeanessentialcomplementtomonetaryunion,byeasingtheburdenofmonetarypolicytofulfilits
pricestabilitymandatebylimitingpotentialunintendedsideeffectsofunion-widemonetarypolicymeasures.
Thedirection(build-uporrelease)ofcapital-basedmeasuresprimarilyreactstothebuild-upof,and/orstillexistingunaddressedfinancialvulnerabilitiesormaterialisationof,riskstobanks’capitalandprofitabilityconditionsandtothestageofthefinancialcycleinconjunctionwiththebusinesscycle,whilethe
inflationaryandmonetaryenvironmentaffectsthetiming,extentandspeedofthis.Whenthefinancialcycleturnsnegative,macroprudentialpolicyshouldfocuson
strengtheningbankresilience,regardlessofthemonetarypolicystance.The
marginalgainsofincreasingbuffersarelargerforcountriesthatdonothavethemyet.Intheinitialriskmaterialisationphase,authoritiesmaydecideto(partially)
releasecyclicalbuffers,whileinthedisorderlyriskmaterialisationphaseitwilllikelyprovenecessarytoreleasecyclicalbuffers,actinginthesamedirectionasmonetarypolicy.Intheearlybuild-up/neutralphaseofthefinancialcycle,bufferscouldbebuiltuppre-emptively,whereasintheexuberancestage,macroprudentialandmonetarypoliciesarelikelytomoveintandeminatighteningdirection.Thedirectionofcapital-basedmeasureswillalsodependonprevailingandexpectedbankcapitaland
profitabilityconditionsandonanysignsofbindingcapital-relatedsupplyconstraints.Inthisregard,theinflationaryandmonetaryenvironmentwillaffecttheintensity,
speedandextentofthebuild-uporreleaseofcapitalbufferswithineachstageofthefinancialcycle.
BBMshavebecomeoneofthekeyinstrumentsinthemacroprudentialtoolkitoverthelasttenyearswhenitcomestobuildingresilience.Theirprimarygoalistobuildresilienceamonghouseholdsbyreducingtheriskofover-indebtedness,promotingtheadoptionofprudentlendingstandardsandmakinghousehold
financingmoresustainable,thusimprovingthequalityofbankloanbooksand
makingthefinancialsystemmoreresilient.TheeffectivenessofBBMsandtheir
costsfortheeconomydependonthefractionofborrowerswhosedebtdecisionis
ultimatelyconstrainedbythemeasures.Incountrieswheretheyhavebeenactivatedsofar,BBMsarelargelyperceivedasstructuralmeasuresandarenotmeantto
substantiallychangeacrossthefinancialcycle.Whiletheirusehasbecome
widespreadoverthelasttenyears,itstillremainsheterogeneousacrossEuropeancountries,alsointermsoftheirspecificdesignatnationallevel.
ECBOccasionalPaperSeriesNo3585
Thenatureofinflationaryshocks(supplyversusdemandside)andthe
prevailingmonetarypolicystanceaffectthebindingnessofBBMs.Inflationarypressuresrelatedtosupply-sideshocks(demand-sideshocks),aswellasmonetarypolicytightening(loosening)tendtomakeincome-basedBBMsmore(less)binding.Atthesametime,monetarypolicytighteninghasalessdirectandmoreambiguouseffectonLTVlimits.
Thecurrentmacro-financialenvironmentincreasesthebenefitsassociatedwithBBMs,especiallyforcountrieswherefloatingratemortgagesdominate.
Followingasubstantialmonetarytightening,suchastheonewehavewitnessed
overthepasttwoyearsorso,thebenefitsassociatedwithBBMsincrease,
particularlyforcountrieswithpredominantlyfloatingratemortgages.However,toreducepotentialexcessivebindingnessandpossibleundesiredprocyclicaleffects,macroprudentialauthoritiesmightchangeexemptionquotasandmaturitylimitstoadjustthebindingnessofthemeasures.
ECBOccasionalPaperSeriesNo3586
1Introduction
1.1Context
Thispaperaimstoassesstheimplicationsofhighinflationandrisinginterestratesformacroprudentialpolicystance.Ouranalysisaddressestheappropriatedirectionandimpactofmacroprudentialpoliciesatthedifferentstagesoffinancial
andbusinesscycles,givencross-countryandbankingsystemheterogeneities.Oneofthegoalsofouranalysisistoassesstheextenttowhichtheinteractionbetweenmacroprudentialandmonetarypoliciesdiffers,giventhedegreeofheterogeneity
acrosseuroareacountriesexposedtoahomogenousmonetarypolicy.Relevantdimensionsofsuchheterogeneitiesincludetheprevalenceoffixedorfloatingratemortgages,thestageatwhicheachcountryfindsitselfinthefinancialcycleand
levelsofinflation,ortherelativeimportanceofnon-bankfinancialintermediaries.
Monetarypolicyandinflationconsiderationshaveplayedanincreasingrole
formacroprudentialauthoritiesintheirpolicysettingsince2022,asindicatedinnotificationstotheESRB/ECB(BoxA).Thenotificationssuggestthathigherinterestratesandinflationwereassessedtohavecontributedtoanincreaseinrisks,
uncertaintyand/orprobabilityofriskmaterialisation.Thisledmosteuroarea/EuropeanUnion(EU)countriestorebuildorevenincreasetheirmacroprudentialbuffersinthefollowingthepandemic.
Asmonetaryandmacroprudentialpoliciesbothoperatetoalargeextent
throughthebankingsystem,theirinteractioncanresultincomplementaritiesandtrade-offstoeachother’seffectiveness.Theoptimalmixofmonetaryand
macroprudentialpolicydependsonthedifferentstagesinthefinancialandbusinesscycle,onthelevelofinflation,onthecapitalpositionandprofitabilityofthebankingsystem,onthenatureandmagnitudeofshocksandexistingvulnerabilities,andonthespecifictypeofpoliciesimplemented(Section2).
Thedirection(build-uporrelease)ofcapital-basedmeasuresprimarilyreactstothebuild-uporexistenceofunaddressedfinancialvulnerabilities,tothe
materialisationofrisks,tobanks’capitalandprofitabilityconditionsandtothestageofthefinancialcycleinconjunctionwiththebusinesscycle.Beyondtherelevantunderlyinginterdependenciesbetweenthefinancialcycleandmonetary
policy,thesourceofinflationaryshocks(supplyversusdemandside)andthe
prevailingmonetaryregimewillaffecttheintensity,speedandextentof
macroprudentialpolicysettingwithineachstageofthefinancialcycle(Section3).
Structuralmodelsallowtoassesshowmonetarypolicycaninfluence
macroprudentialpolicybyaffectingthecourseofthefinancialcycleandthe
costsandbenefitsofphasinginorreleasingmacroprudentialmeasures.Inthisreport,modelsimulationsusingdifferentversionsofastructuralmodel(theso-called“3Dmodel”)highlightthesepolicyinteractionsinvariousanalyticalboxes.The3D
modelisamacro-financialstructuralmodelshowinghowmacroprudentialpolicycanaffectbankresilienceandhowthefinancialsectorinteractswiththerestofthe
ECBOccasionalPaperSeriesNo3587
economy(Clercetal.,2015,andMendicinoetal.,2020).Tostudytheinteraction
betweenmacroprudentialpolicyandmonetarypolicy,theversionsusedintheboxesalsoincludemonetarypolicyshocks(Espicetal.,2024,Mendicinoetal.,2024,andHerreraetal.,2024).1BoxBshowsthatmonetarypolicy,byaffectingthecourseofthefinancialcycle,canhaveindirectimplicationsforthespeedofthecountercyclicalcapitalbuffer(CCyB)build-up,shouldthemacroprudentialauthorityfollowarule-
basedapproach.ThesimulationsinBoxCsuggestthatthereleaseofcapitalbufferscanactpositivelyoncreditandGDPbycreatingmacroprudentialspaceforbanks
(lendingchannel).However,expostlesscapitalisedbankswouldincreasethe
overallriskintheeconomy(riskchannel),partiallyoffsettingthepositiveeffectsof
therelease.Inaninflationaryenvironment,shouldthemonetarypolicyresponsebemoreaggressive,theeffectoftheexpostriskchannelwouldbegreater,makingthereleasemoredetrimentalincaseofinitiallylowbankcapitalisation.Asshown
inSection4,monetarypolicycanalsoaffectthebindingnessofBBMsand,therefore,thecostsofphasing-in.BoxDestimateshowthebindingnessofBBMshasevolvedacrosstherecentmonetarypolicytighteningcycleusingempiricalmicrosimulations.ThestructuralmodelsimulationsinBoxEshowhowchangesinbankprofitability
andinthebindingnessofBBMscanaffectthephase-incostsofcapitalrequirementsandofBBMsrespectively.Asecondsetofsimulationsinthisboxindicatesthat,in
caseofdisorderlyriskmaterialisation,previouslyphased-inmacroprudential
measurescanhelpreducethenegativeeffectsofriskmaterialisationfollowing
monetarypolicytighteningperiods.Therefore,thedesignofBBMsshouldinclude
elementsofflexibility,viaexemptionclauses,sothatadjustmentscanbemadein
responsetothenatureoftheeconomicorinflationaryshocksthattakeplaceandtotheprevailingmonetarypolicystance.
1.2Macroprudentialpolicyinanevolvingmacro-financiallandscape
Challengesanduncertaintiesarisefromthecurrenteconomicenvironment,withinflationpersistentlyabovetarget,havingtriggeredamoreintenseandlastingmonetarypolicytightening.Thisenvironmentisstillcharacterisedby
uncertaintyregardingtheevolutionofinflation,futuremonetarypolicystanceandfinancialmarketreactions.ThefinancialcyclehasturnednegativeinmostEU
countries,withrealestatepricesandvaluationsreflectingdownwardpressureandcreditgrowthslowing.
Thebusinessandfinancialcycleshavebecomede-synchronisedand
inflationarysupplyshocksinthecontextofthepandemicandgeopoliticaltensionsintheeuroareahaveposedachallengetotheclassicalnotionof“complementarity”betweenmacroprudentialandmonetarypoliciesgoing
1Espicetal.(2024)andMendicinoetal.(2024)featurethreelayersofdefault(banks,firmsandhouseholds).Espicetal.(2024)isusedtostudyhowcapitalrequirementsaffectedmonetarypolicytransmissionin2021-23.Mendicinoetal.(2024)isusedtoassesstheroleofthereleaseintheeconomyanditsinteractionswithmonetarypolicy.Finally,Herreraetal.(2024)isusedtoassesshowmonetarypolicycanaffectthecostsandthebenefitsofBBMsandcapitalrequirements,viachangesinbankprofitability,BBMbindingnessandfinancialvulnerabilityamongagents.
ECBOccasionalPaperSeriesNo3588
forward.Measuresrelatingtotheeuroarea’sbusinessandfinancialcyclessuggestanincreasingdivergencebetweenbothpolicies,bothinrealandinnominalterms
overtheextendedCOVID-19period.Whileforsynchronisedfinancialandbusinesscycles,complementarymacroprudentialandmonetarypoliciesmaylargelymoveinthesametighteningorlooseningdirection,de-synchronisedcyclesandinflationarysupplyshockscomplicatetheinteractionbetweenmacroprudentialandmonetary
policies.
Thelevelofaccumulatedrisksandvulnerabilitieshasremainedsignificant.
Mostnationalauthoritieshaveconsideredmonetarypolicyconcernsfor
macroprudentialmeasurestakenin2022andbeyond,suggestingthatthehigher
interestratesandhighlevelsofinflationhavecontributedtotheincreaseinshort-
termrisks,uncertaintyand/orprobabilityofriskmaterialisationrelevantfortheir
decisions.Especiallyincountrieswithahighproportionoffloatingratemortgages,
risinginterestratesmaybecomeasignificantburdenforhighlyindebtedhouseholds,apartfromslowingdowndemandforcreditandhousepurchases(BoxA).
Sincethepandemic,thebuild-upofcapital-basedmeasureshasfocusedon
preservingbankingsectorresilience.2Mosteuroarea/EUcountrieshaverebuiltorevenincreasedtheirmacroprudentialbuffers(forbothcountercyclical(CCyB)and(sectoral)systemicriskbuffers(s)SyRB))followingthepandemic.3Theyaimedto
furthertightenthepolicystanceoratleasttokeepthelevelofcapitalbuffersinplacetoensurebankingsectorresilienceagainstthebackdropofbuilt-upvulnerabilities.
Thisre-focusonresiliencetookplaceamidthesubstantialcumulatedcyclicalandstructuralvulnerabilitiesandthelikelydeteriorationinassetqualityalongtheentiremonetarypolicytighteningcyclethatwouldconsumebankcapitaloverthemediumterm.Sofar,therehavebeennosignsofchangetothismomentumintheformofreleasesorloweringofcapitalrequirements.
BBMshavebecomeoneofthekeyinstrumentsinthemacroprudentialtoolkitoverthelasttenyears.4BBMsencompassprimarilycollateral-basedandincome-basedcreditlimitsandarepredominantlyappliedtomortgages.5Collateral-basedBBMsapplyacreditlimitbasedontheborrower’scollateralvalue(loan-to-value
(LTV)orloan-to-collateral(LTC)).Income-basedBBMsrestricttheamountofcreditordebtinrelationtotheborrower’sdisposableincome(D/LTI)ordebtservice
capacity,whichcannotexceedaspecifiedfractionoftheirdisposableincome
(debt/loanservice-to-incomeratio,orD/LSTI).Inaddition,somemacroprudentialauthoritiesapplymaturitylimitstotheextensionofmortgagesoramortisation
requirements.6
2SeealsoECB(2023a),Chapter5,andBehnandLang(2023),Section2.
3Individualcountrieshavemaintainedtheircapitalbuffersthroughoutthepandemic(e.g.,LUmaintainedtheCCyBandmostcountries,exceptforEE,FI,NLandPL,maintainedtheSyRB).
4ForanoverviewofdifferentBBMsimplementedineuroareaandotherEUcountries,seeLagaria(2023).
5However,insomecases,income-basedBBMsareappliedtoalldebtsoftheborrower.Therefore,theyalsorestrictothertypesofloans,suchasconsumerloans.
6Somecountrieshavealsoimposedspecificrequirementsconcerningtheamortisationscheduleofloans.Forexample,inSlovakia,newcreditagreementsshouldbegrantedwithregularpaymentsofinterestandcapital.InSweden,mortgagorswithlargeloansrelativetotheirincomemustamortiseacertainpercentageoftheirdebteveryyear.
ECBOccasionalPaperSeriesNo3589
Acrosscountrieswheretheyhavebeenactivatedsofar,BBMsarelargely
perceivedasstructuralmeasuresandarenotmeanttosubstantiallychangeacrossthefinancialcycle.Whiletheirusehasbecomewidespreadoverthelasttenyears,heterogeneitypersistsacrossEuropeancountries,alsointermsoftheirspecificdesignatthenationallevel.Forsomecountries,BBMshavebeeninplaceforalongtime(CY,NL,IE,PTandSI),whileothercountrieshaveadoptedthem
morerecently(FR,LU,BE,LVandAT).Alargenumberofcountrieshaveactivated
acombinationofconstraints(L/DTI,L/DSTIandLTV),7whereasothershavefocusedonimplementingauniquelimit(FRforDSTI).
EventhoughpolicydecisionsonBBMshavebeenquitescarcesofar,there
wereafewpolicychangesofalooseningnatureamongEuropeanEconomic
Area(EEA)countriesin2023.Thehighinterestrateandhighinflationenvironmentrendersincome-relatedBBMs,suchaslimitsonD/LSTIandD/LTIratios,more
binding,becausedebtserviceisincreasinganddisposableincomeisdecreasinginrealterms.
BoxA.Overviewofmonetarypolicyconcernsinmacroprudentialnotifications8
Notificationsregardingcapital-basedmeasures
Monetarypolicyandinflationconsiderationswerepresentinthenotificationsofcapital-
basedmeasuresduringbothlowandhighinflationperiodsthroughout2015-23buthave
becomemoreprominentsince2022ChartA.1,leftpanel).Theanalysisofkeywordsrelatedto
inflationandmonetarypolicy9suggeststhatmonetarypolicyconcernswereincreasinglycited
amongtheunderlyingreasonsfornationalauthorities’notificationsoverthe2016-19period(ChartA.1,middlepanel).Thesharethendecreasedthroughout2020and2021amidtheCOVID-19
pandemic,aspandemic-relatedeconomicandfinancialstabilityissuesmovedintofocus.In2022and2023,wheninflationincreasedandmonetarypolicytightened,monetarypolicyconcerns
becamemoreprominentinnationalnotifications(morethan60%ofallnotifications).Duringthesetwoyears,monetarypolicyconcernswerealsocitedbyahighernumberofcountries(ChartA.1,rightpanel).
7SeveraleuroareacountrieswithanLTVlimitinplacehavealsoimposedaD/LSTIoraD/LTIlimit,
溫馨提示
- 1. 本站所有資源如無特殊說明,都需要本地電腦安裝OFFICE2007和PDF閱讀器。圖紙軟件為CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.壓縮文件請(qǐng)下載最新的WinRAR軟件解壓。
- 2. 本站的文檔不包含任何第三方提供的附件圖紙等,如果需要附件,請(qǐng)聯(lián)系上傳者。文件的所有權(quán)益歸上傳用戶所有。
- 3. 本站RAR壓縮包中若帶圖紙,網(wǎng)頁內(nèi)容里面會(huì)有圖紙預(yù)覽,若沒有圖紙預(yù)覽就沒有圖紙。
- 4. 未經(jīng)權(quán)益所有人同意不得將文件中的內(nèi)容挪作商業(yè)或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文庫網(wǎng)僅提供信息存儲(chǔ)空間,僅對(duì)用戶上傳內(nèi)容的表現(xiàn)方式做保護(hù)處理,對(duì)用戶上傳分享的文檔內(nèi)容本身不做任何修改或編輯,并不能對(duì)任何下載內(nèi)容負(fù)責(zé)。
- 6. 下載文件中如有侵權(quán)或不適當(dāng)內(nèi)容,請(qǐng)與我們聯(lián)系,我們立即糾正。
- 7. 本站不保證下載資源的準(zhǔn)確性、安全性和完整性, 同時(shí)也不承擔(dān)用戶因使用這些下載資源對(duì)自己和他人造成任何形式的傷害或損失。
最新文檔
- 工作績(jī)效協(xié)議書
- 律師入職協(xié)議合同
- 快遞保密協(xié)議書
- 藥店竄貨協(xié)議書
- 總包索賠協(xié)議書
- 藥品運(yùn)輸協(xié)議書
- 戰(zhàn)略規(guī)劃協(xié)議書
- 運(yùn)輸績(jī)效協(xié)議書
- 銷售合同保密協(xié)議
- 要錢協(xié)議書范本
- 奮斗的主題班會(huì)課件
- 電務(wù)段干部考試題及答案
- 委托加工項(xiàng)目管理制度
- 2025年單次式拉絲機(jī)項(xiàng)目市場(chǎng)調(diào)查研究報(bào)告
- 紅薯創(chuàng)業(yè)項(xiàng)目計(jì)劃書
- 健美操運(yùn)動(dòng)智慧樹知到期末考試答案2024年
- Web設(shè)計(jì)與應(yīng)用智慧樹知到期末考試答案2024年
- 營(yíng)養(yǎng)支持在ICU的應(yīng)用課件
- +山東省煙臺(tái)市芝罘區(qū)2023-2024學(xué)年七年級(jí)上學(xué)期期末數(shù)學(xué)試卷(五四制)+
- 課程設(shè)計(jì)DLP4-13型鍋爐中硫煙煤煙氣袋式除塵濕式脫硫系統(tǒng)設(shè)計(jì)
- 中科院生態(tài)學(xué)考博真題題匯總
評(píng)論
0/150
提交評(píng)論