ORIGINALARTICLEANINVITROANALYSISOFELEMENTALRELEASEANDCYTOTOXICITYOFRECASTNICKELCHROMIUMDENTALCASTINGALLOYSNAGAMRAJAREDDYANANDAPANDIANPONSEKARABRAHAMKRISHNANMURUGESANVASANTHAKUMARMATSARECEIVED30DECEMBER2010/ACCEPTED22MAY2011/PUBLISHEDONLINE3JUNE2011C211INDIANPROSTHODONTICSOCIETY2011ABSTRACTRECASTINGOFTHECASTINGALLOYSAFFECTSTHECOMPOSITIONANDELEMENTALRELEASEWHICHMAYHAVECYTOTOXICEFFECTDIFFERENTFROMTHEPUREALLOYINTHESURROUNDINGTISSUESANINVITROSTUDYWASCONDUCTEDTOINVESTIGATETHEELEMENTALRELEASEANDTHEIRCYTOTOXICEFFECTSFROMCOMMERCIALLYAVAILABLENICRDENTALCASTINGALLOYS,COMMONLYUSEDFORFABRICATINGFIXEDPARTIALDENTURESTHREENICRALLOYSWIRON99A,CERAMETB,ANDHINICKELCBCWERETESTEDALLOYSPECIMENSDISKS395MMWERECASTEDANDGROUPEDASFOLLOWSGROUPIA1/B1/C1100PUREALLOYGROUPIIA2/B2/C250NEWWITH50RECASTANDGROUPIIIA3/B3/C3100RECASTDISKSOFEACHALLOYTYPEFROMEACHGROUPWERETRANSFERREDTODULBECCOSMODIFIEDEAGLEMEDIUMANDLEFTFOR3DAYSAT37C176CINANATMOSPHEREOF5CO2NI,CR,CO,CUANDMOELEMENTALRELEASEFROMMETALALLOYSINTOCULTUREMEDIUMWASINVESTIGATEDUSINGINDUCTIVELYCOUPLEDPLASMAMASSSPECTROMETRYCYTOTOXICITYWASTESTEDUSINGMOUSEFIBROBLASTCELLSANDMTTASSAYCONTROLSCONSISTEDOF6WELLSCONTAININGCELLSWITHNOALLOYSPECIMENSDATAWEREANALYZEDBYTWOWAYANALYSISOFVARIANCEFOLLOWEDBYTTESTTHETOTALAMOUNTOFELEMENTSRELEASEDINPARTSPERBILLIONFORVARIOUSCASTINGGROUPSWEREGROUPI,A16572,B16732,C18407GROUPII,A222046,B226450,C229189GROUPIII,A384554,B388359,C392264MOREAMOUNTSOFELEMENTSWERERELEASEDINHINICKELCBTHANCERAMETANDWIRON99INALLTHETHREETESTGROUPSPERCENTAGEOFVIABLECELLSFROMMTTANALYSISWEREGROUPI,A162342,B161322C160593,GROUPII,A258699,B256494,C252688,GROUPIII,A353101,B352195,C347586THEVIABLECELLSPRESENTINTHECULTUREMEDIAWEREMOREINWIRON99THANCERAMETANDHINICKELCBELEMENTALRELEASEINCREASEDWITHAMOUNTOFRECASTALLOYAMONGSTTHETHREEALLOYSTESTEDHINICKELCBHADSIGNIFICANTLYHIGHERELEMENTSRELEASEDCOMPAREDTOCERAMETANDWIRON99IN100PUREALLOYS,50RECASTAND100RECASTALLOYSWIRON99SHOWEDLEASTELEMENTRELEASEIN100PUREALLOY,50RECASTAND100RECASTSPECIMENS100PUREALLOYSOFALLTHREEALLOYSARELESSCYTOTOXIC,BUTTHEIRCYTOTOXICITYISMOREON50AND100RECASTEDALLOYSOUTOFALLTHREEVARIATIONSOFCASTINGWIRON99WASLEASTCYTOTOXIC,FOLLOWEDBYCERAMETANDHINICKELCBRECASTINGOFALLOYSSIGNIFICANTLYINCREASEDTHEELEMENTSRELEASEDANDTHEIRCYTOTOXICITYKEYWORDSRECASTINGC1CYTOTOXICITYC1ELEMENTALRELEASEC1DENTALCASTINGALLOYSC1BASEMETALINTRODUCTIONADVANCESINSCIENCEANDTECHNOLOGYINTHEFIELDOFDENTALMATERIALSCIENCEHAVELEADTOTHEINVENTIONOFBASEMETALALLOYSFORAPPLICATIONINDENTISTRY1INTRODUCTIONOFCHROMEALLOYSHASPROVIDEDANALTERNATIVETOGOLD,WITHTHESERESULTEDINNICRANDCOCRBASEDALLOYSWHICHARECLINICALIMPLICATIONSCASTRESTORATIONSPLACEDINCLOSECONTACTWITHORALTISSUESFORVARIOUSPERIODSOFTIMEMAYELICITLOCALADVERSETISSUEREACTIONSSUCHASGINGIVITISANDPERIODONTITISADJACENTTOTHEMDEGREEOFCYTOTOXICITYANDBIOCOMPATIBILITYOFDENTALCASTINGALLOYSHASBEENRELATEDTOALLOYCOMPOSITIONANDELEMENTSRELEASEDFROMALLOYSINTOSURROUNDINGMEDIUMRECASTINGOFNICRALLOYSINCREASESTHEAMOUNTOFELEMENTSRELEASEDANDHENCETHECYTOTOXICPOTENTIALNRREDDYCKSTEJAINSTITUTEOFDENTALSCIENCES,TIRUPATHI,ANDHRAPRADESH,INDIAAPABRAHAMTABLE1ALLOYSHAVEBEENCODEDFORSIMPLICITYANDREFERENCEPURPOSESPREPARATIONOFALLOYSPECIMENSANALUMINIUMMETALDIEWITHACIRCULARSPACEOF5MMRADIUSAND3MMDEPTHWASMILLEDINTHECENTREPORTIONOF1CMTHICKALUMINIUMBLOCKUSINGCOMPUTERIZEDMILLINGMACHINEFIG2WAXPATTERNS10MMINDIAMETER93MMTHICKNESSWEREPREPAREDWITHGREENINLAYCASTINGWAXFIG3BEGOGERMANYUSINGTHEMETALDIEATOTALOF108WAXPATTERNSWEREMADEFORTHREEALLOYSFORGROUPI100PUREALLOYA1/B1/C1,GROUPII50PURE50RECASTALLOYA2/B2/C2,ANDGROUPIII100RECASTEDALLOYA3/B3/C3CASTINGOFTHEPATTERNTHEWAXPATTERNSOFTHETHREEGROUPSWERESEGREGATEDASGIVENINTABLE2THESPRUEDWAXPATTERNSWEREINVESTEDINPHOSPHATEBONDEDINVESTMENTINMETALCASTINGRINGWITHDRYCELLULOSEPAPERRINGLINERFOLLOWINGTHISTHEYWERECASTEDBYLOSTWAXTECHNIQUEINANINDUCTIONCASTINGMACHINEFIG4BEGOGERMANYWITHTHERESPECTIVEALLOYSMETALSUSEDFORRECASTINGWASOBTAINEDFROMCLEANEDLEFTOVERSPRUESANDBUTTONSOFTHEALLOYSTHATHADBEENPREVIOUSLYCASTINGROUPIAFTERBENCHCOOLINGTHECASTINGRINGWASDIVESTEDANDSANDBLASTEDUSING250LMALUMINIUMOXIDETOREMOVETHEREMNANTINVESTMENTMATERIALSPRUESWERECUTOFFANDSPECIMENSWEREFINISHEDANDPOLISHEDUSINGCARBORUNDUMDISCS,METALTRIMMERS,RUBBERWHEELS,SANDPAPERSANDPOLISHINGCAKEUSINGHANDMOTORINSTRUMENTSTHEPOLISHEDDISKSWERESOAKEDINADETERGENTSOLUTIONFOR5MINANDTHENSCRUBBEDUSINGASOFTBRISTLEBRUSHANDRINSEDUNDERTAPWATERFOR5MINSPECIMENSWERETHENREPLACEDINSTERILEDISTILLEDWATERANDCLEANEDBYSONIFICATIONANDAUTOCLAVEDATATEMPERATUREOF150C176CFOR60MINELEMENTALRELEASESIXDISKSOFEACHALLOYTYPEFROMEACHGROUPWERETRANSFERREDTO6MLOFDULBECCOSMODIFIEDEAGLEMEDIUMDMEMANDINCUBATEDFOR3DAYSAT37C176CINANATMOSPHEREOF5CO2DMEMISPREPAREDBYSUPPLEMENTINGWITH5NEWBORNCALFSERUM,100U/MLOFPENICILLIN,STREPTOMYCINAND025LGM/LAMPHOTERICINBFIG5THEMEDIAWASANALYZEDFORPRESENCEOFNI,CR,MO,CO,ANDCUUSINGANINDUCTIVELYCOUPLEDPLASMAMASSSPECTROMETRYICPMSMEDIUMWASDILUTEDWITHDEIONIZEDWATERANDKEPTINICPMSANDTHEREADINGSWERERECORDEDTRIPLICATEABSORBANCEWASUSEDTODETERMINETHEMEANCONCENTRATIONOFDIFFERENTELEMENTSINPARTSPERBILLIONPPBRELEASEDFROMALLOYSFIG1NICRALLOYSFORMETALCERAMICJINDIANPROSTHODONTSOCAPRJUNE2011112106112107123CELLCULTUREANDCYTOTOXICITYTESTFORCYTOTOXICITYTEST,THEREMAINING6DISKSFROMVARIOUSCASTINGALLOYSINTHREEGROUPSWEREPLACEDINCENTEROFA24WELLTISSUECULTUREPLATEAND05MLOFMOUSEFIBROBLASTCELLSUSPENSIONWASADDEDTOCELLWELLFIG6ANDWERELEFTFOR2HFOLLOWINGTHIS05MLOFDMEMWASADDEDANDCELLSWEREINCUBATEDFOR3DAYSAT37C176CINANATMOSPHEREOF5CO2THECONTROLSCONSISTEDOF6WELLSCONTAININGCELLSWITHNOALLOYSPECIMENSAFTERTHEINCUBATIONPERIODTHEPLATESWEREREMOVEDFROMINCUBATORANDCYTOTOXICITYOFTABLE1DESCRIPTIONOFNICRDENTALCASTALLOYSCOMPOSITIONASPROVIDEDBYMANUFACTURERSERIALNOTRADENAMEMANUFACTURERCOMPOSITIONWTCODE1WIRON99BEGOGERMANYNICKEL65ACHROMIUM225MOLYBDENUM95NIOBIUM1SILICA1IRON05CESIUM052CERAMETLABOLINEEUROPENICKEL62BCHROMIUM26MOLYBDENUM10SILICA15OTHERS053HINICKELCBHIKARIJAPANNICKEL60CCHROMIUM10COPPER15MANGANESE79OTHERS71FIG2MILLEDDIEFIG3WAXPATTERNSFIG4CASTSPECIMENSTABLE2DISTRIBUTIONOFSPECIMENSGROUPTYPENOOFALLOYSPECIMENAWIRON99BCERAMETCHINICKELCBI100NEW12A112B112C1II50NEW50RECAST12A212B212C2III100RECAST12A312B312C3108JINDIANPROSTHODONTSOCAPRJUNE2011112106112123MATERIALSWASASSESSEDBYMEASURINGSUCCINICDEHYDROGENASEACTIVITYSDHOFTHECELLSBYUSINGMTTASSAYMTTREAGENTISADDEDTOTHECULTUREPLATEWITHALLOYSPECIMENSANDITISTRANSFERREDTO96WELLPLATESFORREADINGSINENZYMELINKEDIMMUNOSORBENTASSAYELISAREADER,THEPROTOCOLFOLLOWEDFORTHEMTTASSAYISSUMMARIZEDINTABLE3THEREADINGSWERECALCULATEDBYTHEFORMULACELLVIABILITYMEANABSORBANCEOFSAMPLEC2100MEANABSORBANCEOFCONTROLSTATISTICALANALYSISTHERESULTSOBTAINEDFROMTHEMTTANALYSISANDICPMSANALYSISWASSUBJECTEDTOSTATISTICALANALYSISONEWAYANOVAWASUSEDTOCALCULATETHEPVALUEMULTIPLERANGETESTSBYTUKEYHSDPROCEDUREWEREEMPLOYEDTOIDENTIFYTHESIGNIFICANTGROUPSAT5LEVELRESULTSELEMENTALRELEASEELEMENTALRELEASEWASSEENINALLTHREECASTINGALLOYGROUPSELEMENTSRELEASEDWERENI,CR,CO,CUANDMOTABLES4,AND5SUMMARIZETHEELEMENTALRELEASEBYDIFFERENTCASTEDALLOYSINTHREECASTINGPROCEDURESHINICKELCBHADTHEHIGHESTAMOUNTOFELEMENTALRELEASEAMONGTHETHREECASTINGALLOYSFOLLOWEDBYCERAMETANDWIRON99ELEMENTALRELEASESIGNIFICANTLYINCREASEDWITHTHEPERCENTAGEOFRECASTMATERIALUSEDINFORALLELEMENTSANALYZEDINTHESTUDYWITHP005GRAPH1CYTOTOXICITYRESULTSTHEPERCENTAGEOFVIABLECELLSINTHREEGROUPSISTABULATEDINTABLE6MEANPERCENTAGESOFCELLACTIVITYOFTHREEBASEMETALALLOYSFORTHREECASTINGCONDITIONSWEREANALYZEDANDCYTOTOXICITYWASOBSERVEDTOBEMOREINHINICKELCB,FOLLOWEDBYCERAMETANDWIRON99RESULTSSHOWEDTHAT100RECASTALLOYSHADMORECYTOTOXICITYTHAN50PUREAND50RECASTEDAND50PUREAND50RECASTEDALLOYHADMORECYTOTOXICITYTHANPUREALLOYGRAPH2DISCUSSIONMETALSHAVEBEENANINTEGRALPARTOFDENTALRESTORATIVEPROCEDURESDENTALCASTINGALLOYSWHICHRESTORETHEFORMANDFUNCTIONOFMISSINGTOOTHSTRUCTURESHOULDBEBIOLOGICALLYINERTRELEASEOFMETALLICELEMENTSFROMDENTALCASTINGALLOYSISAPOTENTIALHEALTHPROBLEM2,8METALIONSLEACHEDFROMCASTINGALLOYSAREKNOWNTOCAUSETOXICINFLAMMATORY,ALLERGICORMUTAGENICREACTIONS9,10THESERELEASEDELEMENTSHAVEBEENDETECTEDBYINVITROANDINVIVOSTUDIESANIMPORTANTCONSEQUENCEOFELEMENTRELEASEISITSCYTOTOXICEFFECTONADJACENTTISSUEANDTHEAMOUNTOFTISSUEREACTIONDEPENDSUPONELEMENTRELEASED57,11,12FIG5DULBECCOSMODIFIEDEAGLEMEDIUMDMEMFIG6TISSUECULTUREPLATEWITH05MLOFMOUSEFIBROBLASTCELLSUSPENSIONTABLE3PROTOCOLFORPERFORMINGMTTASSAYSTEPACTION1PLATECELLSAT1,000100,000PERWELL2INCUBATEFOR624H3ADD10LLMTTREAGENT4INCUBATEFOR24HUNTILPURPLEPRECIPITATEISVISIBLE5ADD100LLDETERGENTREAGENT6LEAVEATROOMTEMPERATUREINTHEDARKFOR2H7RECORDABSORBANCEAT570NMJINDIANPROSTHODONTSOCAPRJUNE2011112106112109123THESELECTIONOFANALLOYFORSPECIFICCONDITIONSLIKEFIXEDPARTIALDENTURESAREINFLUENCEDBYTHREEFACTORSNAMELYPHYSICALPROPERTIES,BIOCOMPATIBILITYANDCOSTGOLDCONSIDEREDASTHEHIGHNOBLEMETALWASTHEALLOYOFCHOICEFORRESTORATIVEPROCEDURESANDITWASCONSIDEREDTHATNOIONSLEACHEDFROMITBUT,HISTOLOGICALSTUDIESDISPROVEDTHISMISCONCEPTION2HIGHCOSTOFGOLDHASLEADTOTHEINTRODUCTIONOFBASEMETALDENTALCASTINGALLOYS2,3NICKELCOMBINEDWITHCHROMIUMFORMSHIGHLYCORROSIONRESISTANTALLOY,THESEBASEMETALALLOYSWHICHAREPRIMARILYNICKELBASEDCOMPAREDWITHGOLDALLOYSARECHEAPER,HAVEHIGHELASTICMODULUSSTIFFER,HARDER,LESSDENSEANDPOSSESSCOMPARABLERESISTANCETOTARNISHANDCORROSION1DUETOCOMPARABLEPHYSICALPROPERTIESBASEMETALSHAVESLOWLYREPLACEDGOLDCASTINGALLOYS2,3,13,14COMMERCIALLYAVAILABLEBASEMETALALLOYSFORFIXEDPARTIALDENTURESAREUSUALLYNICRALLOYS1,2THECOMPOSITIONOFTHESEALLOYSMAYVARYACCORDINGTOMANUFACTURERBUTTHEBASICCONSTITUENTSARENI,CRANDMO1ADDITIONOFMINORCOMPONENTSSIGNIFICANTLYCHANGESTHEMICROSTRUCTUREANDPROPERTIESWHICHAFFECTTHEBONDSTRENGTHOFCERAMICTOMETALOXIDELAYERREQUIREDFORACHIEVINGBONDINGITISATTHEMANUFACTURERSDISCRETIONTOINCLUDEANYOFTHESEMINORCOMPONENTSTOPRODUCETHEDESIREDPROPERTIES1TABLE4COMPARISONOFMEANVALUESOFELEMENTALRELEASEBETWEENDIFFERENTRECASTEDALLOYSINTHREECASTINGGROUPSGROUPVARIABLEMATERIALMEANSDPVALUESIGNIFICANTGROUPSAT5LEVELI100PUREALLOYA11095005200001SIGC1VSA1ANDB1B111220081C114010082II50PURE50RECASTEDALLOYA23674028800001SIGC2VSA2ANDB2B244080231C248650296III100RECASTEDALLOYA314092073900001SIGC3VSA3ANDB3B3147272028C3149442301TABLE5THEAMOUNTOFVARIOUSELEMENTRELEASEDFROMCASTINGALLOYSFORTHREECASTINGGROUPSMEANSDELEMENTALLOYGROUPIGROUPIIGROUPIIINIWIRON990495001029010169121800633CERAMET0402001236640399135802088HINICKELCB04870090335402993029424225CRWIRON99007100150090002102220077CERAMET034600440084001401080076HINICKELCB026500920458009104710104COWIRON99002900080074000700620036CERAMET004800210035000700650013HINICKELCB002700100436012800510015MOWIRON99050100530621011816290195CERAMET034300510524008409410055HINICKELCB041600290044003101430042CUWIRON99CERAMETHINICKELCB020700560573015649181047GRAPH1COMPARISONOFELEMENTRELEASEFORTHREEALLOYS110JINDIANPROSTHODONTSOCAPRJUNE2011112106112123THEPERMISSIBLELEACHINGOFTHESEELEMENTSSHOULDBEEVALUATEDTOPREVENTUNTOWARDSIDEEFFECTSCYTOTOXICEFFECTSDURINGFUNCTIONITHASBEENAPRACTICETOFURTHERREDUCETHECOSTTHECASTEDALLOYISREUSEDAGAININVARIOUSPROPORTIONSWITHNEWALLOY3THEELEMENTALRELEASEOFTHISRECASTEDALLOYMAYVARYFROMTHEPUREVIRGINALLOYTHEBIOCOMPATIBILITYOFTHEALLOYDEPENDSUPONTHETYPEANDELEMENTALRELEASEFROMIT,INTOSURROUNDINGMEDIUMORTISSUES5,15TOASSESSTHEELEMENTRELEASEDFROMTHEALLOYS,THEALLOYISSTOREDINASUITABLEMEDIUMSUCHASARTIFICIALSALIVAFOR3MONTHSORINASUITABLECULTUREMEDIUMANDINCUBATEDFOR3DAYS1619STORINGTHESPECIMENINCULTUREMEDIUMANDINCUBATINGITISAPRACTICALMETHODASTHEPROCEDUREREQUIRESSHORTERSPANOFTIMEANDTHEELEMENTSRELEASEDWEREALSOBETTER16FURTHERTOEVALUATETHEAMOUNTOFELEMENTSRELEASEDINTOTHEMEDIUMVARIOUSMETHODSHAVEBEENPUTFORTH,SUCHASATOMICABSORPTIONSPECTROGRAPHY,EMISSIONSPECTROGRAPHY,INDUCTIVELYCOUPLEDPLASMAATOMICEMISSIONSPECTROPHOTOMETERICPAES,INDUCTIVELYCOUPLEDPLASMAMASSSPECTROMETRYICPMS20ICPMSISFAST,SENSITIVE,PRECISEANDACCURATEMULTIELEMENTANALYTICALTECHNIQUEFORDETERMINATIONOFTRACEELEMENTSTHECOMMONMETHODSUSEDTOEVALUATECYTOTOXICITYAREMILLIPOREFILTER,AGAROVERLAYTEST,MTTASSAYTESTMTTASSAYISANEASYTECHNIQUETHEREADINGSCANBECALCULATEDDIRECTLYFROMELISAREADER16THEOTHERADVANTAGESOFMTTARESENSITIVEANDREPRODUCIBILITY,CONVENIENT,RAPIDITY,ELIMINATIONOFNEEDOFRADIOACTIVECOMPOUNDSANDECONOMICALTHREENICRBASEDALLOYSWIRON99,CERAMETANDHINICKELCB,COMMONLYUSEDFORTHEFABRICATIONOFMETALCERAMICFIXEDPARTIALDENTURESFROMDIFFERENTPOPULARMANUFACTURINGCOMPANIESWERECHOSENDUETOTHEVARIATIONINTHEIRCOMPOSITIONCLAIMEDBYTHEMANUFACTURERSCLEANINGANDSTERILIZATIONOFSPECIMENSWEREPERFORMEDACCORDINGTORECOMMENDEDPROTOCOLSSPECIMENSWEREAUTOCLAVED150C176CFOR60MINPRIORTOTESTINGTOSTERILIZETHEM1,16ITISIMPORTANTTONOTETHATTHISPROCEDUREMAYAFFECTTHECORROSIONPATTERNOFTHESEALLOYS,HOWEVERALLTHEALLOYSPECIMENSRECEIVEDTHESAMETREATMENT,THUSANYDIFFERENCESINCYTOTOXICITYOFELEMENTALRELEASEWOULDBERESULTOFDIFFERENCESINTYPEANDCOMPOSITIONOFALLOYSORTHECASTINGPROCEDURESTHEFINDINGSOFTHECURRENTSTUDYAGREEDWITHTHEHYPOTHESISTHATRECASTINGOFBASEMETALALLOYSINCREASESTHEIRPOTENTIALCYTOTOXICEFFECTANDELEMENTRELEASEINTHESTUDY,ELEMENTRELEASEINALLTHENEWALLOYSAMPLESWASSIGNIFICANTLYLESSTHANTHERECASTEDSPECIMENSAMONGSTTHETHREEALLOYSSELECTEDHINICKELCBHADSIGNIFICANTLYHIGHERELEMENTSRELEASEDCOMPAREDTOCERAMETANDWIRON99INPUREALLOY,50RECASTAND100RECASTALLOYSWIRON99SHOWEDLEASTELEMENTRELEASEIN100PUREALLOY,50RECASTAND100RECASTSPECIMENSALLTHEBASEMETALALLOYSTESTEDINTHISSTUDYSHOWEDTOHAVEACYTOTOXICEFFECTINTHECYTOTOXICEVALUATIONDONEBYANALYZINGLIVINGCELLSANDPERCENTAGEOFCELLVIABILITYITWASSEENTHATIN100PUREALLOYSPECIMENSWIRON99,CERAMETANDHINICKELCBWERECYTOTOXICINTHEINCREASINGORDERWITHRECASTINGOFALLOYSEITHERWITH50OR100SHOWEDADEFINITEDECREASEINTHENUMBEROFLIVINGCELLSINALLTHETHREEALLOYSINTHEPRESENTSTUDYIN50NEW50RECASTEDAND100RECASTED,THEMEANOFLIVINGCELLSANDPERCENTAGEOFCELLVIABILITYAREMORESIGNIFICANTINWIRON99THANCERAMETANDHINICKELCBHINICKELCBSHOWEDLEASTNUMBEROFVIABLECELLSAMONGNICRALLOYSCHOSENHINICKELCBWASMOSTCYTOTOXICANDITWASSIGNIFICANTLYMORECYTOTOXICTHANCERAMETANDWIRON99THISCOULDBERELATEDTOTHEDIFFERENCEINTHECOMPOSITIONOFTHESEALLOYS1,3THEGREATESTCYTOTOXICITYSHOWEDBYTHEHINICKELCBALLOYFORALLTHETHREECASTINGCONDITIONSCOULDBEDUETOITSCOPPERCONTENTITHASBEENREPORTEDINTHELITERATURETHATTHEMAJORCONTRIBUTIONFORTOXICITYOFALLOYSWASPROBABLYDUETOCOPPERCONTENT1ITHASBEENREPORTEDTHATONLYNICRTABLE6MEANVALUESFORPERCENTAGEOFCELLVIABILITYFORTHREECASTINGGROUPSGROUPOFALLOYMATERIALPERCENTAGEOFVIABLECELLSI100PUREA162342B161322C160593II50PURE50RECASTEDA258699B256494C252668III100RECASTEDA353101B352195C347556CELLVIABILITYGRAPH2PERCENTAGEOFCELLVIABILITYJINDIANPROSTHODONTSOCAPRJUNE2011112106112111123ALLOYSCONTAINING1627CRDEVELOPANADEQUATEPROTECTIVEOXIDELAYERMOLYBDENUMALSOHASANACTIVEROLEINTHEFORMATIONOFOXIDELAYERSINCECOPPERBASEDALLOYSTARNISHANDCORRODEMORETHANNONCOPPERALLOYS,ITWASOBSERVEDINTHEPRESENTSTUDYTHATAREMARKABLEAMOUNTOFCOPPERWASRELEASEDINTOCULTUREMEDIUMFROMHINICKELCBTHECONTENTOFCOPPERINASSOCIATIONWITHLOWCONTENTOFCRANDABSENCEOFMOLYBDENUMMAYALSOEXPLAINSIGNIFICANTCYTOTOXICEFFECTOFTHISALLOYINCOMPARISONTOOTHERNICRALLOYS1,3,17THUSFORALLOFTHEALLOYS50RECASTGROUPSWERESIGNIFICANTLYMORECYTOTOXICTHAN100NEWALLOYGROUPSANDFURTHERMORE,THE100RECASTGROUPSWERESIGNIFICANTLYMORECYTOTOXICTHAN50RECASTGROUPTHISCOULDBEDUETOSOMEEFFECTONTHECHEMICALCOMPOSITIONOFTHESEALLOYSWHICHMAYINCREASETHEDISSOLUTIONRATEOFTHEALLOYS,ANDTHUSTHEELEMENTSRELEASEDFROMTHEMWILLBEINCREASEDASFOUNDINICPMSANALYSISFROMTHERESULTSOFPRESENTSTUDYITAPPEARSTHATTHEALLOYTYPESANDTHEELEMENTSOFTHESEALLOYSBECOMEAFFECTEDTOADIFFERENTDEGREEWHENTHEALLOYWASRECASTANDHENCEATTRIBUTESTOITSCYTOTOXICEFFECTSLIMITATIONSTHERESULTSOFTHESTUDYNEEDTOBECORRELATEDCONSIDERINGTHEFOLLOWINGLIMITATIONSTHEMINERALSORORGANICCONSTITUENTSINDMEMMEDIAUSEDMAYHAVEANEFFECTONCORROSIONSUSCEPTIBILITYOFTHEALLOYSANDTHUSINFLUENCETHEELEMENTRELEASEALTHOUGHASMALLSAMPLESIZEN6WASUSEDINTHECURRENTSTUDY,SIGNIFICANTDIFFERENCESWEREFOUNDBETWEENTHEDIFFERENTGROUPS,INDICATINGITSSUFFICIENTLYLARGEEFFECTSIZEHOWEVERFURTHERSTUDIESNEEDTOBECONDUCTEDWITHGREATERSAMPLESIZEFORAMOREADEQUATEREPRESENTATIONOFTHEALLOYTYPESCONCLUSIONSTHERESULTSOBTAINEDFROMTHESTUDYPROVEHYPOTHESISTHATRECASTINGOFBASEMETALALLOYSAFFECTTHEIRELEMENTALRELEASEANDSUBSEQUENTLYELICITCYTOTOXICEFFECTSTHOUGHITHASBEENACCEPTABLETOREUSE50RECASTEDALLOYINTHEFORMOFSPRUESREMOVEDFROMPREVIOUSCASTINGSADDEDTONEWALLOYINGOTTOMAINTAINPHYSICALANDCHEMICALPROPERTIES,THEELEMENTRELEASEFROMTHESERECASTEDALLOYSARESIGNIFICANTLYMOREANDHENCEWILLHAVEADEFINITECYTOTOXICEFFECTWITHINTHELIMITATIONSOFTHECURRENTSTUDYITMAYBECONCLUDEDTHATHINICKELCBSHOWSTHEMAXIMUMELEMENTALRELEASEANDCYTOTOXICITYEFFECTINPUREANDRECASTEDFORMSANDTHISISFOLLOWEDBYCERAMETINTHECURRENTSTUDYWIRON99SHOWEDTHELEASTELEMENTRELEASEANDCYTOTOXICITYREFERENCES1ANUSAVICEKJ2003PHILLIPSSCIENCEOFDENTALMATERIALS,11THEDNSAUNDERS,STLOUIS,PP5636202STEINRS1966PONTICRESIDUALRIDGERELATIONSHIPRESEARCHREPORTJPROSTHETDENT162512853AHMADALHIYASATS,DARMANIH2005THEEFFECTSOFRECASTINGONTHECYTOTOXICITYOFBASEMETALALLOYSJPROSTHETDENT931581644ALHIYASATAS,BASHABSHEHOM,DARMANIH2003ANINVESTIGATIONOFTHECYTOTOXICEFFECTSOFDENTALCASTINGALLOYSINTJPROSTHODONT1618125BRUNED1988MECHANISMSANDKINETICSOFMETALRELEASEFROMDENTALALLOYSINTENDODJ211351426CRAIGRG,HA