I

T/CSPSTC9-2017

Contents

Foreword II

1Range 1

2Normativereferences 1

3Termsanddefinitions 1

4Generalrules 1

4.1evaluationprinciples 1

4.2evaluationstatements 2

4.3definitionofevaluationobject 2

4.4sourcesofdataresources 2

4.5evaluator'srequests 2

5Evaluationindexsystem 2

5.1generalrequirements 2

5.2enterprisetechnologicalinnovationinfluenceindex 5

5.3enterprisebrandinnovationinfluenceindex 9

5.4enterprisemanagementinnovationinfluenceindex 12

6Evaluationmodel 15

6.1theevaluationmodelofsingleitemindexofinnovationinfluence 15

6.2theevaluationmodelofclassifieditemindexofinnovationinfluence 16

6.3theevaluationmodelofcompositevaluesofinnovationinfluence 16

7Evaluationmethod 16

7.1Generalrequirements 16

7.2Evaluationprocess 17

7.3Evaluationreport 17

8Evaluationconclusion 18

8.1Innovationinfluenceindex 18

8.2Innovationinfluenceindexclassification 18

AppendixA 19

(informativeappendix) 19

Enterpriseinnovationinfluenceevaluationreportform 19

II

T/CSPSTC9-2017

Foreword

ThisstandardwasdraftedinaccordancewiththerulesgivenGB/T1.1-2009.

ThisstandardwasproposedbyChinaSocietyforthePromotionofScienceandTechnologyCommercializationandStandardUnitedConsultancyCenter.

ThisstandardisunderthejurisdictionofChinaSocietyforthePromotionofScienceandTechnologyCommercializationStandardizationWorkingCommittee.

ThisstandardwasdraftedbyStandardUnitedConsultancyCenter,ChinaNationalInstituteofStandardization,GreeElectricAppliancesInc.ofZhuhai,HaierGroup,InnerMongoliaFirstMachineryGroupCorporation,CITICDicastalCo.,Ltd.,HengtongGroup,JALAGroup,ShandongYangguCableGroupCo.,Ltd.,CNNCJianzhongNuclearFuelCo.,Ltd.,CRRCQingdaoSifangCo.,Ltd.,LuoyangBearingScience&TechnologyCo.,Ltd.,ChinaNationHeavyDutyTruckGroupCo.,Ltd.,HeilongjiangZhenbaoDaopharmaceuticalCo.,Ltd,MESNACCo.,Ltd.,HenanSONGHEWine-MarketingIndustryCo.,Ltd.,FarEastCableCo.,Ltd.,BeijingOrientalYuhongWaterproofTechnologyCo.Ltd.,CRRCZhuzhouLocomotiveCo.,Ltd.,ShanghaiLiangxinElectricalCo.,Ltd.(Nader),ShandongElectricPowerEngineeringConsultingInstituteCo.,Ltd.(SDEPCI),GuangdongJianmeiAluminumProfileFactory(Group)Co.,Ltd.,HubeiYihuaRefcoGroupLtd,ChinaInstituteofspacescienceandIndustryGroup3rdResearchInstituteNo.31Branch,NingboYongfaIntelligentSecurityTechnologyCo.Ltd.,ShandongPacificOpticsFiberandCableCo.,Ltd.,KatieecologicalenvironmentPolytronTechnologiesInc,KweichowmoutaiCo.,Ltd.,ShandongGRADGroupCo.Ltd.,JingdezhenChangheAutomobileTechnologyImp.&Exp.Co.,Ltd.,MideaGroup,ChinaQualityCertificationCentre,GuangzhouCNSBrandResearchInstitute,TsinghuaUniversity,ZhongguancunStandardInnovationServiceCenter,InnovationAllianceCertificationCenterCorporation,ChinaSocietyforthePromotionofScienceandTechnologyCommercialization.

ThemaindraftersofthisstandardincludesLuChengxu,GaoAng,DongMingzhu,WangYe,DuShaofeng,XuZuo,SunYixing,LiuYuliang,GaoXianwu,DengHua,CaoZhiwei,YeJun,LiYusheng,XuZhaoqin,YuMingjin,LiXuesi,ZhuChangbiao,DuanWenfeng,ZhaoJiangnong,LiBai,WangLonglin,LiLin,ZhouYuhuan,YangXiaoqin,ZengHerong,CaoZhongwei,ZhangChuandong,LuoTingyuan,ZhangLixue,LiuHanlin,GuanYingui,XiaoXiao,HuZiqiang,PanYing,Liwuxian,XiaoGuangling,TianChuan,HuiXiaobing,TanHua.

1

T/CSPSTC9-2017

Evaluationsystemsforenterpriseinnovationinfluence

1Range

Thisstandardspecifiestheevaluationprinciple,evaluationindexsystemandevaluationmethodwhichshouldbefollowedintheevaluationofenterpriseinnovationinfluence.

Thisstandardappliestotheevaluationofenterpriseinnovationinfluenceinalltypesofindustriesandsizes,andprovidesareferenceforenterprisestoform,maintainandpromoteinnovationinfluence.

2Normativereferences

Thefollowingdocumentsfortheapplicationofthisdocumentisessential.Fordatedreferences,onlythedatedversionappliestothisdocument.Forundatedreferences,thelatestedition(includingallamendments)appliestothisdocument.

GB/T19011-2013Guidelinesforauditingmanagementsystems

3Termsanddefinitions

3.1

enterpriseinnovationinfluence

Theenterprisecarriesoutinnovationactivities,achievescommitments,getsrecognitionandgainsresultsintheproduct,brand,management,culture,socialresponsibilityandsoon.Inthisprocess,theenterprisewillbeabletohaveapositiveguidingeffectonthemselvesorrelatedparties.3.2

evaluationsystem

Theevaluationsystemisacompletesystemwhichiscomposedoffactorssuchasevaluationobject,evaluationindexsystem,evaluationprinciples,evaluationmethodsandevaluationprocess.

3.3

index

Anindexisafigureobtainedbyusingeveryelementoftheevaluationsystemintotheoperationlikesuperpositionandsoonaccordingtotheevaluationtarget,whichcaneffectivelymeasurethequantitativeimpactofeveryelementonevaluationobjects.

4Generalrules

4.1Evaluationprinciples

Evaluationofenterpriseinnovationinfluenceshouldfollowthefollowingprinciples:

——Impartial.Accordingtotheactualsituation,theenterpriseinnovationinfluenceisevaluatedobjectively,fairlyandimpartially.

——Scientific.Thedataresourcesoftheevaluationelementsarereliableandcanaccuratelyreflecttheguidanceandrequirementsoftheevaluation.

——Operable.Theevaluationindexsystemandevaluationmethodshouldbespecific,clear,

T/CSPSTC9-2017

2

measurable,easytounderstand,easytooperate.

——Continuousimprovement.Theevaluationsystemofenterpriseinnovationinfluenceshouldbecontinuouslyimprovedtoprovideobjective,fairandadvancedevaluationresults.

Whentheevaluationobjectisharmfultothepublicinterestwillnotbeevaluated.

4.2Evaluationstatements

Beforecarryingouttheevaluationwork,itisnecessaryfortheevaluationagencytodeclaretheexpecteduseoftheevaluationresult,theusersoftheevaluationreport,theevaluationprocess,thequalificationrequirementsoftheevaluator,thetimetoimplementtheevaluationandthelimitationoftheevaluation.

4.3Definitionofevaluationobject

Beforeevaluating,theevaluationagencyshouldidentifytheevaluationobjecttodefinethebusinessareasoftheirproductsorservices,andappointrelevantprofessionalevaluatortoimplementtheevaluation.

4.4Sourcesofdataresources

Theevaluatorshouldensurethateffectiveinformationisobtainedtocarryouttheevaluation,andthesourcesofdataresourcesincludeevaluationobjectandrelatedparties.Theevaluatorsshouldfullyassesstheauthenticity,integrity,consistencyandadequacyofthedataresourcesused.

4.5Evaluator'srequests

Duringtheevaluationprocess,theevaluatorshouldworkbasedontheevaluationprincipleof

4.1andfollowthefollowingrequirements:

-Tobefamiliarwiththecurrentsituationanddevelopmentprospectoftheevaluationobject.

-Tocommunicatewiththemembersoftheevaluationteamtosolvetheproblemsordoubtsintheevaluationprocess.

-Toensuretheoverallandobjectiveevaluationprocess,noartificialadjustmentofthedataortheresults.

-Theactualoperationisconsideredtoensurethattheevaluationprocessisfeasibleandtheevaluationprocesscanbetracedback.

-Theevaluationinformationandtheintermediatedatashouldbestrictlyconfidentialwithoutthepermissionoftheevaluatedenterprise.

-Tocarryoutevaluationworkshouldbeaimedathelpingenterprisetocontinuetoimproveitsinnovationinfluence.

5Evaluationindexsystem

5.1Generalrequirements

5.1.1Evaluationlevel

Theevaluationsystemforenterpriseinnovationinfluenceconsistsofthreelevelsofindexes.Inevaluationsystem,threefirstlevelofindexesareenterprisetechnologicalinnovationinfluenceindex,enterprisebrandinnovationinfluenceindexandenterprisemanagementinnovationinfluenceindex.Therearesixsecondlevelofindexesandtwenty-ninethirdlevelofindexesunderthethreefirst

T/CSPSTC9-2017

3

levelofindexes.

5.1.2Evaluationindex

Theindexoftheevaluationsystemforenterpriseinnovationinfluenceiscalculatedbythestepbystep.Theindexesatalllevelsarecalculatedbythearithmeticorgeometricmeansoftheirnextlevelindexes.Inparticular,thefirstlevelofindexesisthegeometricmeansofeachsecondlevelofindexesunderitscategory,andthesecondlevelofindexesisthearithmeticaverageofthethirdlevelofindexesunderitscategory.TheevaluationsystemforenterpriseinnovationinfluenceisshowninSheet1.

Sheet1Theevaluationsystemforenterpriseinnovationinfluence

firstlevelofindexes

thirdlevelofindexes

secondlevelofindexes

ThenumberofR&DpersonnelaccountforthetotalnumberofemployeesL1P1-A1

ThenumberofR&Dpersonnelabovethegraduatedegreeorabovetheseniortitle

Investmentindexof

technologicalinnovationL1P1

enterprise

technological

innovation

influenceindex

L1

Outputindexof

technologicalinnovationL1P2

accountforthetotalnumberofemployeesL1P1-A2

AnnualR&DinvestmentaccountsfortheproportionofsalesinthepreviousyearL1P1-A3

Themanpowercostofpreviousyear'sR&DpersonnelaccountforthegrossprofitofthepreviousyearL1P1-A4

Annualauthorizednumberofforeignpatents(inventions,utilitymodelsanddesigns)L1P2-A1

Annualauthorizednumberofnationalpatents(inventions,utilitymodelsanddesigns)L1P2-A2

Annualreleasednumberofstandards(internationalstandards,nationalstandards,industrystandards,localstandards,associationstandards)L1P2-A3

AnnualpublishednumberofmonographsandobtainednumberofcopyrightregistrationcertificatesL1P2-A4

AnnualpublishednumberofpapersinprofessionalperiodicalsathomeandabroadL1P2-A5

Theprofitofnewproductsintwoyearsaccountsfortheproportionofsalesrevenue

unit

percentage

percentage

percentage

percentage

item

item

item

item

item

percentage

T/CSPSTC9-2017

4

BrandbuildingindexL2P1

enterprisebrand

innovation

influenceindex

L2

BrandL2P2

reputationindex

enterprise

management

innovation

ManagementindexL3P1

innovation

influenceindex

L3

L1P2-A6

Totalamountoffundsforscientificresearchprojectsatalllevelsoftheyear(Tenthousandyuan)L1P2-A7

Totalamountofgovernmenttechnicalawardsatalllevelsoftheyear(Tenthousandyuan)L1P2-A8

BrandplanningandbrandstrategicinvestmentaccountforgrossprofitinthepreviousyearL2P1-A1

EnterprisecultureconstructioninvestmentaccountforthegrossprofitinthepreviousyearL2P1-A2

AdvertisinginvestmentaccountforthegrossprofitinthepreviousyearL2P1-A3

ThenumberofinnovativechannelsforbrandpromotionL2P1-A4

Thenumberofannualhostingandco-hostingtheindustryconferenceathomeandabroadL2P2-A1

ThenumberofannualoriginalandbenignreportsofallkindsofmediaL2P2-A2

Thenumberofannualentrepreneurs'mediainterviewsL2P2-A3

Thenumberofannualhonorsattheinternational,national,provincialandassociationlevelsL2P2-A4

ThenumberofmanagementmethodsormanagementsystemsimplementedinenterpriseL3P1-A1

ThenumberofadministrativeemployeesabovethegraduatedegreeorabovetheseniortitleaccountforthetotalnumberofadministrativeemployeesL3P1-A2

EmployeeswhohaveparticipatedinandcompletedprofessionaltraininginthepreviousyearaccountforthetotalnumberofemployeesL3P1-A3

Therateofreturnoninvestmentinthe

L3P1-A4

innovativeL3P1-A5

management

previousyearPracticeofmethodology

grading

quantization

grading

quantization

percentage

percentage

percentage

grading

quantization

item

item

item

item

item

percentage

percentage

grading

quantization

grading

quantization

T/CSPSTC9-2017

5

CharitablepublicinvestmentL3P2-A1

quantization

Responsetothegovernment'spolicycallL3P2-A2

CustomersatisfactionL3P2-A3

quantization

ImpactonindustrychainandIndustryL3P2-A4

SocialcontributionindexL3P2

grading

quantization

grading

grading

quantization

grading

5.1.3Descriptionofevaluationindex

Thedescriptionofevaluationindexshowsthefollowing:

1)indexnumber:L:firstlevelofindexes;P:secondlevelofindexes;A:thirdlevelofindexes;

2)nameofindex:thenameoftheevaluationindex;

3)unit:themeasurementunitoftheevaluationindex;

4)calculationmethod:thecalculationmethodoftheevaluationindexvalue;

5)calculationformula:theformulausedinthenumericalcalculationoftheevaluationindex.

5.2Enterprisetechnologicalinnovationinfluenceindex

5.2.1Investmentindexoftechnologicalinnovation

TheevaluationindexandmeasurementmethodoftheinvestmentindexoftechnologicalinnovationareshowninSheet2.

Sheet2evaluationindexofinvestmentindexoftechnologicalinnovation

Numb

er

L1P1-

A1

L1P1-

A2

Nameof

index

The

numberof

R&D

personnel

account

forthe

total

numberof

employees

The

numberof

R&D

personnel

abovethe

graduate

degreeor

abovethe

Measuremethodofindex

X=ThenumberofR&Dpersonnel/totalnumberofemployees

X=ThenumberofR&Dpersonnelabovethegraduatedegreeorabovetheseniortitle/thetotalnumberofemployees

Threshold

range

minX=20%,

maxX=80%

minX=20%,

maxX=80%

Unit

percentage

percentage

Calculation

method

benchmarking

benchmarking

Calculationformula

of

formula6.2

of

formula6.2

T/CSPSTC9-2017

6

seniortitle

account

forthe

total

numberof

employees

L1P1-

AnnualR

X=AnnualR&D

minX=10%,

percent

benchmarki

formula

of

A3

&D

investmen

taccounts

forthe

proportion

ofsalesin

the

previous

year

investmentaccounts/theproportionofsalesinthepreviousyear

maxX=50%

age

ng

6.2

L1P1-A4

The

manpower

costof

previous

year'sR&

D

personnel

account

forthe

gross

profitof

the

previous

year

X=Themanpowercostofpreviousyear'sR&Dpersonnel/thegrossprofitofthepreviousyear

minX=10%,

maxX=50%

percentage

benchmarking

formula6.2

of

5.2.2Outputindexoftechnologicalinnovation

TheevaluationindexandmeasurementmethodoftheoutputindexoftechnologicalinnovationareshowninSheet3.

Sheet3evaluationindexofoutputindexoftechnologicalinnovation

UnitCalculation

method

itembenchmarki

ng

Misthegradeofaforeignpatent,andmisthenumberofpatentscorrespondingtoM.

Thevalueofaforeign

Nameof

index

Annual

authorized

numberof

foreign

patents

(invention

s,utility

MeasuremethodofindexThreshold

range

Calculation

formula

formulaof

6.2

Number

L1P2-A1

minX=0,maxX=50

X=M*m

T/CSPSTC9-2017

7

modelsand

designs)

patentgradeisasfollows:Invent=1

Utilitymodel=0.8Design=0.6

L1P2-

Annual

X=ΣM*m

minX=0,

itembenchmarki

formula

of

A2

authorized

maxX=100

ng

6.2

numberof

national

patents

(invention

s,utility

models

and

designs)

Misthegradeofanationalpatent,andmisthenumberofpatentscorrespondingtoM..

Thevalueofanationalpatentgradeisasfollows:Invent=1

Utilitymodel=0.8Design=0.6

L1P2-

Annual

X=ΣN*M*m

minX=0,

itembenchmarki

formula

of

A3

released

maxX=20

ng

6.2

numberof

standards

(internatio

nal

standards,

national

standards,

industry

standards,

local

standards,

associatio

n

standards)

Nisthesinglestandarddevelopmentcontributiondegree,Misthestandardgrade,andmisthenumberofdraftingstandardscorrespondingtoNandMatthesametime.

Thesinglestandarddevelopmentcontributiondegreeistakenasfollows:Host=1(ranking1-3)

Mainparticipationin=0.6(ranking4-6)

Participatein=0.3(afterranking6)

Thevalueofthestandardgradeisasfollows:

Internationalstandard=1Nationalstandard=0.8

Industrystandard=0.7Groupstandard=0.6Localstandard=0.5

L1P2-A4

Annual

published

X=Σm

minX=0,

maxX=50

itembenchmarking

formula6.2

of

numberof

monograp

misannualpublishednumberofmonographs

T/CSPSTC9-2017

8

hsand

obtained

numberof

copyright

registratio

n

certificate

s

andobtainednumberofcopyrightregistrationcertificates(theenterprisemustbethefirstsignatureunit)

L1P2-

Annual

X=M*m

minX=0,

item

benchmarki

formula

of

A5

published

maxX=80

ng

6.2

numberof

papersin

profession

al

periodical

sathome

and

abroad

Misthegradeofpaperspublished,andmisthenumberofprofessional

journalarticles

correspondingtoM.

Thevalueofthepaperspublishedgradeisasfollows:

SCI/EIJournal=1

Corejournal=0.6

OpenissueJournal=0.4

L1P2-

Theprofit

X=Theprofitofnew

minX=0,

percenta

benchmarki

formula

of

A6

ofnew

products

intwo

years

accounts

forthe

proportion

ofsales

revenue

(Ten

thousand

yuan)

productsintwoyears/theproportionofsalesrevenue

maxX=80%

ge

ng

6.2

L1P2-A7

Total

amountof

fundsfor

scientific

research

projectsat

alllevels

oftheyear

(Ten

thousand

Whentotalamount=0,X=0;

Whentotalamountismorethan0andlessthan100,X=25;

Whentotalamountismorethan100(including100)andlessthan500,X=50;

Whentotalamountis

minX=0,

maxX=100

grading

quantization

benchmarking

formula6.2

of

T/CSPSTC9-2017

9

yuan)

morethan500(including500)andlessthan1000,X=75;

Whentheamountisnotlessthan1000,X=100

L1P2-A8

Total

amountof

governme

nt

technical

awardsat

alllevels

oftheyear

(Ten

thousand

yuan)

Whentotalamount=0,X=0;

Whentotalamountismorethan0andlessthan50,X=25;

Whentotalamountismorethan50(including50)andlessthan100,X=50;

Whentotalamountismorethan100(including100)andlessthan200,X=75;

Whentheamountisnotlessthan200,X=100

minX=0,

maxX=100

grading

quantization

benchmarking

formula6.2

of

5.3Enterprisebrandinnovationinfluenceindex

5.3.1Brandbuildingindex

TheevaluationindexandmeasurementmethodofthebrandbuildingindexareshowninSheet4.

Sheet4evaluationindexofbrandbuildingindex

Numb

er

L2P1-

A1

L2P1-

A2

Nameof

index

Brand

planning

andbrand

strategic

investmen

taccount

forgross

profitin

the

previous

year

Enterprise

culture

constructi

on

Measuremethodofindex

X=brandplanningandbrandstrategicinvestment/grossprofitinthepreviousyear

X=enterprisecultureconstructioninvestment/thegrossprofitinthepreviousyear

Threshold

range

minX=0,

maxX=10%

minX=0,

maxX=10%

Unit

percentage

percentage

Calculation

method

benchmarking

benchmarking

Calculationformula

of

formula6.2

of

formula6.2

T/CSPSTC9-2017

10

investmen

taccount

forthe

gross

profitin

the

previous

year

percentage

benchmarking

X=Advertising

investment/thegross

profitinthepreviousyear

formula6.2

minX=0,

maxX=10%

of

L2P1-A3

Advertisin

g

investmen

taccount

forthe

gross

profitin

the

previous

year

benchmarking

Whenthenumberof

innovativechannelsfor

brandpromotion=0,X=0;

Whenthenumberof

innovativechannelsfor

brandpromotionismore

grading

quantiza

tion

of

formula6.2

minX=0,

maxX=100

L2P1-A4

The

numberof

innovative

channels

forbrand

promotion

than0andlessthan3,

X=25;

Whenthenumberof

innovativechannelsfor

brandpromotionismore

than3(including3)and

lessthan6,X=50;

Whenthenumberof

innovativechannelsfor

brandpromotionismore

than6(including6)and

lessthan9,X=75;

Whentheamountisnot

lessthan9,X=100

5.3.2Brandreputationindex

TheevaluationindexandmeasurementmethodofthebrandreputationindexareshowninSheet5.

Number

Nameofindex

Sheet5evaluationindexofbrandreputationindex

MeasuremethodofindexThresholdUnitCalculation

rangemethod

Calculationformula

11

T/CSPSTC9-2017

L2P2-A1

The

numberof

X=ΣN*M*m

minX=0,

maxX=100

itembenchmarki

ng

formula6.2

of

annual

hosting

and

co-hosting

the

industry

conferenc

eathome

and

abroad

Nistheresponsibilityunitlevel,Misaconferencelevel,misthenumberofmeetings.

ThevalueoftheresponsibilityunitNistakenasfollows:

hostmeeting=1

hostingmeeting=0.8

co-hostingmeeting=0.6

ConferencelevelMistakenasfollows:

InternationalConference=1

Domesticconference=0.8

L2P2-A2

The

numberof

X=Σm

minX=0,

maxX=100

itembenchmarki

ng

formula6.2

of

annual

original

and

benign

reportsof

allkinds

ofmedia

misthenumberofannualoriginalandbenignreportsofallkindsofmedia

L2P2-A3

The

numberof

X=Σm

minX=0,

maxX=20

itembenchmarki

ng

formula6.2

of

annual

entreprene

urs'media

interviews

misthenumberofannualentrepreneurs'mediainterviews

L2P2-

The

X=ΣM*m

minX=0,

itembenchmarki

formula

of

A4

numberof

maxX=10

ng

6.2

annual

honorsat

the

internatio

nal,

national,

provincial

and

associatio

nlevels

Misthevalueofthehonor,andmisthenumberofhonorscorrespondingtoM

Thevalueofthehonorisasfollows:

International=1

Nationallevel=0.8

Provinciallevel=0.6Associationlevel=0.4

T/CSPSTC9-2017

12

5.4Enterprisemanagementinnovationinfluenceindex

5.4.1Managementinnovationindex

TheevaluationindexandmeasurementmethodofthemanagementinnovationindexareshowninSheet6.

Sheet6evaluationindexofmanagementinnovationindex

Numb

er

L3P1-

A1

L3P1-

A2

L3P1-

A3

Nameof

index

The

numberof

managem

ent

methods

or

managem

ent

systems

implement

edin

enterprise

The

numberof

administra

tive

employees

abovethe

graduate

degreeor

abovethe

seniortitle

account

forthe

total

numberof

administra

tive

employees

Employee

swho

have

participate

dinand

completed

profession

Measuremethodofindex

X=m

misthenumberofmanagementmethodsormanagementsystemsimplementedinenterprise

X=Thenumberofadministrativeemployeesabovethegraduatedegreeorabovetheseniortitle/totalnumberofadministrativeemployees

of

in

X=Thenumber

employeesparticipating

andcompletingoneormoreprofessionaltrainingfortheyear/Totalnumberofemployees

Threshold

range

minX=0,

maxX=10

minX=20%,

maxX=80%

minX=20%,

maxX=100%

Unit

item

percenta

ge

percenta

ge

Calculation

method

benchmarking

benchmarking

benchmarking

Calculationformula

of

formula6.2

of

formula6.2

of

formula6.2

T/CSPSTC9-2017

13

altraining

inthe

previous

year

account

forthe

total

numberof

employees

benchmarking

Whentherateofreturnon

investmentis=0,X=0;

Whentherateofreturnon

investmentislessthan

5%,X=25;

Whentherateofreturnon

investmentismorethan

grading

quantiza

tion

minX=0,

maxX=100

of

formula6.2

L3P1-A4

Therate

ofreturn

on

investmen

tinthe

previous

year

5%(including5%)and

lessthan10%,X=50;

Whentherateofreturnon

investmentismorethan

10%(including10%),

X=100

benchmarking

Practiceof

innovative

managem

ent

methodolo

gy

grading

quantiza

tion

of

formula6.2

minX=0,

maxX=100

L3P1-A5

Themethodologyof

innovationmanagementis

missing,X=0;

Themethodologyof

innovationmanagement

hasbeenavailable,andit

canguidethepracticeof

enterpriseinnovation

activities,X=60;

Theinnovation

management

methodologyissoundand

canpromotethepractice

ofenterpriseinnovation

activities,X=100

5.4.2Socialcontributionindex

TheevaluationindexandmeasurementmethodofthesocialcontributionindexareshowninSheet7.

Sheet7evaluationindexofsocialcontributionindex

Number

Nameofindex

Measuremethodofindex

ThresholdrangeUnitCalculationmethod

Calculationformula

T/CSPSTC9-2017

14

L3P2-

A1

L3P2-

A2

L3P2-

A3

Charitable

public

investmen

t

Response

tothe

governme

nt'spolicy

call

Customer

satisfactio

n

Charitablepublic

investmentislowerthanlastyear,X=0.

Charitablepublic

investmentisflatwith

lastyear,X=60;Charitable

investmentis

public

higher

thanlastyear,X=80;

publicis

Charitableinvestment

significantlyhigherthanlastyear,X=100

Theagreementbetween

the

strategyenterprisenationalindustrial

development ofthe andtheandregionaldevelopment

policyislow,

Itisingood

withthe

development

X=80;

Itisinclose

X=60;

agreement

industrialpolicy,

agreement

withthedevelopmentX=100

The

industrialpolicy,

customer

satisfactionislow,thecomplaintismuch,X=0;

Customerssatisfied

arealmostwiththe

qualityoftheproductandservice,X=60;

Customersaresatisfiedwiththequalityofthe

andservice,

productX=80;

very

the

are

with

Customerssatisfied

qualityoftheproductsandservices,X=100

minX=0,

maxX=100

minX=60,

maxX=100

minX=0,

maxX=100

grading

quantiza

tion

grading

quantiza

tion

grading

quantiza

tion

benchmarking

benchmarking

benchmarking

formula

6.2

formula

6.2

formula

6.2

of

of

of

T/CSPSTC9-2017

15

L3P2-A4

Impacton

industrychain

and

Industry

Ithasalowimpactonindustrialchainandindustrydevelopment,X=0;

Thereisacertaineffect,X=60;

Ithasagoodeffect,X=80;

Toupgradeindustrialchainandindustry,X=100

minX=0,

maxX=100

grading

quantization

benchmark